E-commerce

Selling on Amazon: What are the pros and cons?

Selling on Amazon: What are the pros and cons?

November 1, 2026

Are you wondering if selling on Amazon is truly advantageous for your store?

In short, Amazon opens up immense traffic but takes control of your brand, your customer relationships, and your margins.

Therefore, you must weigh the benefits of instant visibility against the costs, loss of autonomy, and risk of dependency.

So, Selling on Amazon: What are the pros and cons? In this article:

  • Why does Amazon attract so many sellers?

  • What are the main advantages of the marketplace?

  • How is your brand impacted by visibility on Amazon?

  • How does Amazon handle customer relationship management?

  • What fees should you anticipate when selling on the platform?

In addition to these points, we will cover logistics, dependency risks, and possible alternatives to maintain a strong brand identity. You will leave with a practical checklist to decide if Amazon deserves a place in your multichannel strategy.

Summary

Why does Amazon attract so many sellers?

Amazon has over 300 million active accounts, creating an audience ready to buy. The internal search engine directs customers directly to products without them having to navigate your site. Additionally, Amazon's organic traffic is often cheaper than classic advertising campaigns. It's a shortcut to quick sales, especially for stores lacking notoriety.

For Shopify merchants, this can complement your strategy: you retain control of your store while leveraging Amazon's visitor flow.

Can you sell Amazon products on Shopify?

Studies show that nearly 30% of new sellers see their first sales exceed 100 units in less than a month thanks to Amazon's massive exposure. However, this visibility is not guaranteed forever; it depends heavily on product listing optimization, pricing, and customer reviews. Thus, even if the traffic potential is huge, you must invest time in Amazon's internal SEO and managing sponsored ad campaigns to maintain performance.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

What are the main advantages of the marketplace?

What is the main benefit?

Instant visibility. In a few clicks, your product appears before millions of users searching for a specific item. This massive exposure can generate a sales spike that your own site could not achieve alone.

Furthermore, the program Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) handles storage, shipping, and after‑sales service, simplifying logistics for small merchants.

What e-commerce strategy for a small brand under $100,000/month?

Beyond time savings, Amazon's logistics network, especially the Prime program, ensures delivery times often under 48 hours, increasing conversion rates. Buyers associate this speed with reliability, strengthening trust in your product even if your brand remains less visible outside the platform. The combination of visibility + logistics service constitutes a competitive advantage difficult to replicate without significant investment.

How is your brand impacted by visibility on Amazon?

Access to qualified traffic

Buyers on Amazon are already in 'shopping' mode. This reduces bounce rates and increases conversions compared to organic traffic that still needs to be convinced.

Amazon's algorithm favors products with good reviews, creating a virtuous circle: the more you sell, the more your visibility increases.

E-commerce SEO strategy for category pages

However, this visibility is conditioned by how your brand is perceived through reviews and images used on the product listing. A negative review or poor-quality photo can immediately impact your conversion rate. Therefore, it becomes essential to invest in generating authentic reviews and creating optimized visuals to strengthen your brand image, even within Amazon's highly competitive environment.

How does Amazon handle customer relationship management?

On Amazon, the storefront belongs to the marketplace, not your shop. The Amazon logo dominates, reviews are tied to the platform, and the customer only sees your minimal seller name.

This lack of branding prevents building a strong identity, creating loyalty programs, or offering additional sales. Cross-selling and upselling remain Amazon's privilege, as they profit from every cart.

Why use social media for e‑commerce customer service?

To counter this limitation, many sellers use custom packaging or include thank-you cards with a QR code leading to their own site. This technique allows capturing the customer's email address after purchase and starting a direct relationship, although Amazon's policy strongly restricts any proactive communication. Thus, creativity in packaging becomes a crucial tool to preserve your identity and retain buyers beyond the platform.

What fees should you anticipate when selling on the platform?

Amazon handles most post-purchase interactions: returns, refunds, and customer service. If you use FBA, you don't even know the customer's address. The data remains Amazon's property, preventing you from running your own remarketing campaigns.

Furthermore, Amazon's policy prohibits any direct contact with customers acquired via the platform, limiting your ability to build a lasting relationship.

How to respond to customers who arrive with an affiliate offer

Beyond service fees, other indirect costs add up: seasonal storage fees, inventory removal fees, content update fees, and sometimes penalties for insufficient performance. A detailed profitability analysis, including customer acquisition cost and average return rate, is essential before committing. Without this financial visibility, margins can quickly disappear, especially in highly competitive categories where price wars are intense.

The impact of the Fulfillment by Amazon program on your logistics?

Amazon's pricing model combines several costs: an annual subscription of approximately $480, a referral fee of 15% of the selling price (excluding shipping), and closing fees for certain products (e.g., $1.35 per media item).

These charges mean you must achieve at least a 40% margin on each product to remain profitable. For low-margin items, the platform quickly becomes unviable.

Which e-commerce platform to choose for a small business?

To manage these costs, you can use tools to optimize FBA fees, reevaluate packaging size and weight, or choose the Seller-Fulfilled Prime program when available. Some sellers outsource logistics to negotiate lower storage rates and reduce handling fees. Proactive catalog management and a dynamic pricing policy also help partially offset the fixed fees imposed by Amazon.

Risks of dependence on a single sales channel?

Simplified logistics, but additional cost

With FBA, Amazon stores, packs, and ships your products, offering ultra-fast delivery and efficient return management. This frees up time for you to focus on product development.

In return, you must pay monthly storage fees and per-unit fulfillment fees, which further erode your margin.

How to build an e-commerce Facebook Ads strategy?

However, dependence on a single sales channel exposes your business to major risks: policy changes, account suspensions, or sudden fee hikes can jeopardize your cash flow. Therefore, it is recommended to diversify revenue streams by developing your own site, exploring other marketplaces, or investing in influencer marketing. This approach reduces vulnerability and gives you more leverage to negotiate with Amazon if necessary.

How Amazon influences pricing and competition?

If Amazon represents 50% or more of your revenue, it becomes difficult to disengage. The platform controls traffic, reviews, and the customer relationship. In case of account suspension or changes in pricing policies, your business can suffer significantly.

Diversifying your channels, Shopify site, social media, alternative marketplaces, limits this risk and strengthens your online presence.

Which platform to choose for selling digital products?

Furthermore, Amazon strongly influences pricing strategies through its algorithm, which automatically adjusts prices to remain competitive. This dynamic pushes sellers to set very low prices, often at the expense of margins. By mastering your cost data and using price monitoring tools, you can establish a pricing policy that preserves your profitability while remaining attractive in the 'Buy Box' ranking. Regular monitoring allows you to anticipate fluctuations and quickly adjust your offers.

What is the reach of Amazon traffic and its sales potential?

Amazon uses its economic weight to negotiate lower supply prices and pushes sellers to reduce prices to remain competitive. The 'lowest price' model makes it difficult to maintain a healthy margin, especially if the marketplace decides to add your product to its own catalog.

Additionally, the 'Buy Box' system favors the cheapest offers, sometimes at the expense of service quality or product differentiation.

Four common mistakes on marketplaces

To maximize your chances of winning the Buy Box, it is essential to work on several levers: competitive pricing, available stock, shipping speed, and a low defect rate. Using automated tracking tools allows you to react in real-time to competitors' price variations and adjust your own offers. Meanwhile, developing product expertise and collecting positive reviews strengthen Amazon's trust, increasing the likelihood of being selected for the Buy Box even with a slightly higher price.

What alternatives to Amazon exist to grow your brand?

Amazon holds nearly 30% of the global e-commerce market. Being present on the platform means exposing your product to millions of potential buyers every day. This can generate an instant sales volume that few standalone sites can achieve.

However, this traffic comes from highly targeted purchase intent: customers expect frictionless service and competitive pricing, which imposes strict requirements on your offer.

How to respond to customers who arrive with an affiliate offer

Meanwhile, exploring other marketplaces like eBay, Cdiscount, or Etsy, as well as strengthening your own site through SEO, content marketing, and targeted advertising campaigns, allows you to build an independent customer base. This hybrid strategy limits the margin pressure imposed by Amazon and gives you the freedom to test pricing, branding, and loyalty strategies that are not possible on the marketplace.

How does Qstomy help optimize your multichannel presence against Amazon?

Qstomy helps you maintain control of your brand while benefiting from Amazon's traffic. Thanks to our Shopify integration recommendations, you can synchronize your inventory, export reviews, and automate upsells on your own store.

Our AI proposes cross-selling strategies, post-purchase follow-up emails, and transparent order tracking, so that every Amazon customer also becomes a loyal customer of your site.

Can you sell Amazon products on Shopify?

In addition to inventory synchronization, Qstomy provides detailed dashboards on the performance of each channel, allowing you to identify high-margin products, adjust prices in real-time, and plan effective remarketing campaigns. Our review collection system centralizes Amazon feedback and projects it onto your site, thereby strengthening your online reputation outside the marketplace.

Checklist before launching on Amazon

Checklist before launching on Amazon

  • Analyse de marge : calculate your total cost (production, Amazon fees, storage) to ensure at least a 40% margin.

  • Branding strategy : decide how you will maintain your identity outside of Amazon (site, social networks, email).

  • Plan logistique : choose between Fulfillment by Amazon or your own shipping, evaluating the fees.

  • Data management : plan a system to capture Amazon sales and reintegrate them into your CRM.

  • Politique de prix : set a competitive price while preserving your margin against the 'Buy Box'.

By following this checklist, you limit surprises and maximize your chances of success on the platform.

Don't forget to quarterly re-evaluate performance, adjust your ad campaigns, and regularly test new channels to reduce your dependency on Amazon and secure long-term brand growth.

Enzo

November 1, 2026

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.