E-commerce

What payment fraud risks to monitor during the holidays?

What payment fraud risks to monitor during the holidays?

October 27, 2026

Wondering what payment fraud risks to monitor during the holidays? The short answer: two threats dominate, account takeover and coupon abuse. Both surge at Christmas when order volume explodes and vigilance wanes.

Fraud incidents increase proportionally to holiday sales. Fraud varies by product category and company size: mid-sized multichannel merchants suffer higher rates than small sellers, often because the latter review every order manually. The trap: believing fraud only affects others, or treating every signal as a simple anomaly.

So what payment fraud risks to monitor during the holidays? On the agenda:

  • Why does payment fraud rise with Christmas sales?

  • How does account takeover work?

  • What signals should trigger manual verification?

  • En quoi consiste l’abus de coupons ?

  • How to spot a customer bypassing a purchase limit?

  • What is the role of friendly fraud in all this?

  • Should you invest in a fraud prevention service?

  • How does Qstomy help protect the customer relationship?

  • What checklist to apply before the holidays?

Let's go.

Summary

Why does payment fraud rise with Christmas sales?

Online payment fraud progresses at the pace of sales. The more orders you process, the more attack surfaces you offer. The holiday season concentrates two perfect ingredients: unusual volume and promotions that blur the markers.

According to the Global Fraud Report from Pymnts.com published in October, fraud may have cost the global industry $58 billion last year. The figure is staggering, but it hides a finer reality: fraud is not distributed uniformly.

It varies by product category and company size. Mid-sized multichannel merchants and large enterprises suffer higher rates than small online sellers, mainly because a small merchant handling few orders often examines them one by one. Electronics or jewelry sellers are also more targeted than clothing retailers.

Ce qu’il faut retenir

Your exposure depends on your volume, category, and level of automation. Understanding trends before acting remains the first step.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

How does account takeover work?

Account takeover is a form of identity theft. A criminal gains access to a registered customer's account and poses as that known, trusted customer.

Once logged in with the customer's real credentials, the attacker has several levers. They can use registered payment methods to purchase items, access a loyalty program, or simply place orders with stolen cards hoping to bypass the store's fraud prevention software.

The damage is twofold: the merchant loses the fraudulently ordered merchandise and, often, the customer whose account was compromised. This fraud is costly and spreads quickly.

A rising threat

Javelin Strategy & Research noted a tripling of losses related to account takeover. Sift Science, a fraud prevention software publisher, estimates the cost to the industry at around $5.1 billion in 2017. The fifth edition of the Forter MRC Fraud Attack Index reports a nearly 35% increase in attacks in the first two quarters of 2018.

What signals should trigger manual verification?

The best weapon against account takeover remains observing customer behavior. A change in pattern is not always fraud, but it deserves a closer look.

Take a concrete example: a customer who used the same credit card on their recent orders suddenly starts using new cards and different names. This shift justifies verification.

If your e-commerce platform, order management software, or prevention tools allow it, flag unusual behaviors for human review. Automation detects anomalies, humans judge the context.

Signals to isolate

  • A new payment card after several regular orders.

  • A delivery address that changes with every order.

  • Multiple accounts sharing the same payment method.

  • Unusual volume or value purchases on a dormant account.

A single signal proves nothing. Several aligned signals, however, call for action.

En quoi consiste l’abus de coupons ?

Coupons are an excellent lever to boost sales during the Christmas rush. They also open a door for holiday fraudsters. In many cases, coupon abuse is friendly fraud: the culprit is a customer, not a professional criminal.

Imagine a Cyber Monday promotion. Your store emails a code offering a free 32-inch TV with the purchase of a game console. The code is limited to one per customer. Your store breaks even on the transaction: no profit if the buyer only takes the console. Your hope is that they add some high-margin items.

Everything hinges on the limit of one free TV per customer. A grandmother appears who believes she deserves the offer not once, but four times, for each of her grandchildren. The platform reminds her of the limit. So she cheats: she creates four accounts, using her personal address for one, her professional address for another, etc. She even opens several new email addresses. In her eyes, she has obtained the offer she deserved. In reality, she has committed coupon fraud and deprived your business of its margin.

This may seem harmless since she does buy the consoles. Yet it is coupon abuse. According to the Forter MRC Fraud Attack Index already cited, coupon abuse surged by 217% in the first quarter of 2018.

How to spot a customer bypassing a purchase limit?

Careful monitoring of coupon usage is your best defense. The goal is not to hunt your loyal customers, but to identify patterns that betray a policy circumvention.

Let's revisit the grandmother from earlier. Two or more combinations of console plus TV could target the same delivery address. And for each, she had to provide a real name and a real payment card. It is therefore possible that a single card was associated with multiple customer accounts.

In summary: if something seems odd, check it. This simple reflex catches much friendly fraud without burdening the experience of honest buyers.

Useful overlaps

  • Delivery address shared by multiple accounts.

  • Payment method common to multiple identities.

  • Repeated use of a code intended for single use.

  • Simultaneous orders on freshly created accounts.

What is the role of friendly fraud in all this?

Friendly fraud deserves special attention, as it often slips under the radar. The perpetrator is a customer, not an organized professional. They do not perceive themselves as fraudsters. They simply believe they are entitled to the offer, or that a small deviation does no harm.

The problem is that the final tally is very real for your margin. A coupon diverted four times, multiplied by hundreds of customers, eventually weighs heavily. And since friendly fraud does not trigger the same alerts as card theft, it can thrive for a long time without being detected.

The right approach: distinguish honest error from repeated manipulation. A customer who makes a mistake once calls for a kind reminder. One who creates four accounts and multiple addresses to capture the offer several times is deliberately trying to circumvent your policy.

Should you invest in a fraud prevention service?

Depending on your business segment, you could lose 2 percent of your revenue, or more, due to some form of fraud during the holidays. Put together, this quickly adds up to a significant sum. Enough, in any case, to justify investing in a prevention service.

Options are plentiful: Kount, Sift Science, Forter, LexisNexis Risk Solutions, Riskifed, and many others. A good service analyzes a customer's purchase speed, IP address, recent behavior across multiple e-commerce sites worldwide, and many other data points.

The result takes the form of a score assigned to each purchase. You then set rules around this score and flag or reject orders deemed likely to be fraudulent.

What a good tool does

It doesn't just say yes or no. It cross-references signals and lets you control the risk threshold your store can tolerate.

How does Qstomy help protect the customer relationship?

Fraud prevention must not break the shopping experience. This is where Qstomy plays its role. Qstomy is an AI agent for Shopify that guides the buyer toward the purchase, then supports your customer service team after the order. Over 100 merchants use it daily.

During the holidays, a customer whose order is blocked or delayed by verification may panic or feel wrongly accused. The agent answers frequently asked questions about unavailable payment methods, proposes an alternative without losing the sale, and handles package tracking to ease anxiety.

On categories with high return rates, it also plays a preventive role: a clear size guide, product compatibility verification, or an explanation of possible order consolidation before shipping. You reduce disputes while maintaining a healthy business relationship.

To go further

How to reduce claim reasons that mask fraud?

Not all claims are fraudulent. Many stem from avoidable misunderstandings: a wrong size chosen, uncertain compatibility, an unexplained delay. Yet these legitimate reasons mix with suspicious claims and complicate the reading of your data.

By reducing sources of misunderstanding upstream, you achieve two savings at once: fewer costly returns, and a clearer signal when a request truly stands out.

Analyze product return reasons to tackle the problem at its source. Integrate your customer service responses into a useful e-commerce SEO strategy: each frequent question becomes a page that reassures before purchase and lightens your support load.

Ressources utiles

Why does choosing the right platform also limit fraud?

Your ability to prevent fraud depends partly on the platform powering your store. Some allow flagging unusual behavior for human review. Others facilitate setting rules based on a risk score. Others, more limited, leave you to verify everything manually.

The calculation is simple: the more your tool automates detection, the more time you free up for truly ambiguous cases. A small merchant handling few orders can afford manual review. A merchant whose volume quadruples during Christmas, no.

This is a criterion to integrate at the time of choice, not after. A well-chosen platform gives you control levers: order values, payment behaviors, signals to escalate.

To compare

What checklist to apply before the holidays?

A final simple checklist can spare you many headaches during the holiday season. Here is the essential to review.

In short

  • Flag unusual behaviors : card changes, name changes, or address changes after several regular orders.

  • Monitor coupon usage : shared delivery addresses, common payment method across multiple accounts, reused codes.

  • Activate rules on risk score if your tool allows it, and set a threshold suited to your tolerance.

  • Prepare for human review : who examines doubtful cases during high-traffic days?

  • Reassure legitimate customers A poorly explained verification quickly turns into a negative review.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does fraud also affect small shops? Yes, even though large multi-channel merchants show higher rates. Electronics and jewelry sellers are targeted more than clothing sellers.

Is coupon abuse really fraud? Yes. When a customer creates multiple accounts and addresses to bypass a limit, they commit coupon fraud, even if they actually purchase the product.

When should you invest in a dedicated service? When your estimated loss becomes significant. A loss of 2% of revenue or more justifies the calculation.

How to maintain customer trust during a verification?

A well-conducted verification protects your margin without alienating your customer. Everything hinges on communication. A legitimate buyer who receives a vague message, or worse, no message at all, feels wrongly suspected and makes it known.

Clearly explain what is happening and what is expected. If a payment method causes issues, immediately offer an alternative to avoid losing the sale. If an order requires additional verification, provide a realistic timeline rather than leaving the customer in uncertainty.

This is where Qstomy makes a daily difference: it answers questions about the order, proposes a fallback payment solution, and tracks the package once shipping is initiated.

Holiday fraud is therefore fought on two fronts: well-read signals on the back-office side, and a reassuring customer experience on the storefront side. The two reinforce each other. A well-accompanied customer reduces complaints, making real anomalies more visible. Prepare your rules and messages before the rush: you will approach Christmas with clear benchmarks rather than good intentions.

Enzo

October 27, 2026

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.