E-commerce

Sale of counterfeits: what is the merchant's liability?

Sale of counterfeits: what is the merchant's liability?

October 31, 2026

Are you wondering what your responsibilities are when a counterfeit product appears in your store?

In short, the merchant can be held liable if they do not react quickly to brand reports.

The legal framework is complex: one must both respect trademark law and implement control procedures.

So, selling counterfeits: what is the merchant's liability? Here is the program:

  • What are the legal obligations of a merchant facing counterfeit brands?

  • What does secondary counterfeit liability consist of?

  • How to implement an effective notice-and-takedown policy?

  • What lessons can be drawn from the eBay-Tiffany case for small shops?

  • How does Qstomy help manage counterfeit risks on your Shopify store?

Let's go.

Furthermore, the rise of cross-border marketplaces accentuates the need for constant monitoring, as counterfeit products circulate rapidly from one country to another, pushing e-commerce merchants to adopt multilingual tools and comply with the legal requirements of each jurisdiction.

Finally, adopting a holistic approach, combining technology, internal procedures, and staff training, is the best way to protect your store while maintaining a smooth and secure customer experience.

Summary

What are the legal obligations of a merchant facing counterfeit brands?

The Intellectual Property Code requires any online seller not to market products infringing on a registered trademark. In practice, this means the merchant must verify the origin of items and ensure they are not counterfeit. In case of failure, the trademark holder can hold the seller liable for counterfeiting, even if they are not directly the author of the fraud. The duty of vigilance extends to supervising listings, descriptions, and images presented to consumers.

To protect themselves, it is recommended to implement an internal supplier control procedure and keep purchase invoices as proof of good faith.

Moreover, several major industry players have established quarterly supplier audits, accompanied by a compliance certification, which allows tracing the origin of goods and reacting quickly in case of doubt. This approach, while cost-effective, strengthens consumer trust and reduces litigation risks.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

What does secondary counterfeit liability consist of?

Secondary liability arises when an intermediary, marketplace, host, or reseller knows or should have known about the presence of counterfeit products and takes no action to remove them. Case law, notably the eBay-Tiffany case, clarifies that deliberate negligence exposes the merchant to significant damages. The notion of 'knowledge' can be proven by the absence of monitoring procedures or by the delay in acting following a brand notification.

Thus, even a small e-commerce site must have a rapid takedown mechanism to avoid being considered an accomplice.

Recent case law, notably the Paris Court of Appeal ruling of March 12, 2025, has expanded the notion of knowledge by considering that failing to update a database of known brands could constitute negligence. Thus, regular automated monitoring is now a key element to demonstrate the merchant's good faith.

What criteria does case law use to qualify liability?

Courts rely on three pillars: actual or constructive knowledge of the illegal content, the ability to remove the product, and the lack of reasonable efforts to do so. In eBay's case, the court noted that the platform had implemented a reporting system, over 200 dedicated employees fighting counterfeiting, and rapid takedown procedures. These elements excluded secondary liability.

For small structures, it is sufficient to demonstrate the existence of a notice-and-takedown process and sufficient responsiveness.

For small businesses, it is recommended to use hosted monitoring services that send real-time alerts as soon as a protected brand name appears in a product's metadata. This approach combines the flexibility of a SaaS solution with the traceability required by judges.

This practice shows judges that the merchant has implemented proactive monitoring, which significantly mitigates the risk of secondary liability.

How to implement an effective notice-and-takedown policy?

A notice-and-takedown policy must include:

  • A dedicated point of contact where trademark holders can submit their claims.

  • A processing timeframe clearly indicated (e.g., 48 h) to analyze and remove the infringing product.

  • A documentary register which retains each notification and the action taken, useful in case of litigation.

Integrating these steps into the Shopify dashboard facilitates compliance and shows judges that the merchant acted in good faith.

It is also advisable to establish an internal communication protocol so that each department (marketing, logistics, customer service) knows who to contact and what steps to follow when a notice-and-takedown is triggered. A shared dashboard, automatically updated via the Shopify API, facilitates coordination and reduces processing times.

What technical means can help detect counterfeit ads?

Automated image analysis and keyword comparison tools allow for the rapid identification of suspicious listings. Some SaaS services scan the web for keywords associated with well-known brands and alert the merchant as soon as an inconsistency appears. Integrating third-party APIs into Shopify, for example via compliance control apps, strengthens monitoring and reduces the need for manual intervention.

Associating these solutions with the notice-and-takedown policy creates a robust defense against secondary liability.

Some platforms offer visual fingerprinting functions, which compare image signatures against a database of protected logos. By coupling this technology with semantic analysis of titles, merchants can identify counterfeits even when sellers slightly modify the text or images.

How to respond quickly to trademark holder notifications?

Upon receiving a notification, the merchant must:

  • Verify the authenticity of the claim (product, brand, proof of registration).

  • Immediately remove the product from the catalog and disable the purchase link.

  • Inform the trademark holder of the measures taken and archive proof of removal.

These steps, recorded in the register, limit potential damages and demonstrate good-faith cooperation.

Post-notification follow-up is equally vital: server logs, screenshots of the removed product, and email exchanges must be retained. These elements constitute solid evidence before courts and may be required during an internal or external compliance audit.

What financial risks does a merchant face in case of negligence?

Sanctions may include:
• Damages proportional to the revenue generated from counterfeit products.
• Refund of profits received from consumers.
• High legal fees and, in serious cases, seizure of assets.
Furthermore, the store's reputation is damaged, leading to a loss of trust that often translates into a drop in traffic and sales.

Preventing these risks through a rigorous policy is therefore more economically viable than facing the consequences.

In addition to direct sanctions, liability can lead to the criminal liability of the manager, particularly in cases of recidivism or proven fraud. Customs authorities may also block shipments, impacting the supply chain and increasing operational costs.

Moreover, professional insurance covering counterfeiting risks can mitigate the financial impact of a potential judgment.

What recourse can trademark holders exercise against the merchant?

The rights holder may initiate: a formal notice, a counterfeiting lawsuit before the court, and request provisional measures (seizure of stock, suspension of the site). In case of secondary liability, the retailer may claim damages for the harm suffered, including the cost of fighting counterfeiting. Case law shows that judges assess the merchant's diligence: the faster the actions, the lighter the sanctions.

The trademark owner may also request the suspension of the online store's domain name, or even seek an order to cease activities. This preventive measure aims to quickly eliminate the source of the infringement and protect consumers from potential scams.

How to protect your own brand against imitators?

Systematically register your trademarks with the INPI and regularly monitor online databases. Implement a monitoring program for similar listings, including on third-party marketplaces. If suspicion arises, contact the platforms immediately to assert your rights. Finally, clearly display logos and legal notices on your product pages to limit confusion.

It is also advisable to register linguistic and orthographic variations of the brand name, as well as associated logos, to broaden the scope of the monitoring system. Proactive monitoring on social media and discussion forums allows for early detection of counterfeiting traces before they reach the sales platform.

What lessons can be drawn from the eBay-Tiffany case for small shops?

The case shows that the mere existence of a takedown system is not enough; it must be proven that the merchant actively uses it. For small shops, there is no need to invest millions; the key is to document every report and act quickly. Using Shopify apps that automate reporting and takedowns can compensate for a lack of human resources while meeting legal requirements.

For niche boutiques, using licensing contracts with brands can be a winning strategy: by obtaining explicit authorization to sell certain products, the merchant positions themselves in a cooperative rather than adversarial stance, which limits litigation risks.

How does Qstomy help manage counterfeit risks on your Shopify store?

Qstomy integrates an automatic monitoring solution that analyzes every newly imported product and compares it against protected brand databases. When a suspicious match appears, the tool creates an alert directly in your Shopify dashboard, proposes takedown actions, and logs the process for any future claims. In addition, Qstomy helps you:
Configure a reliable payment gateway,
Optimize your SEO,
Optimize your Google visibility,
and to manage customer support in case of disputes related to removed products. Thus, you are legally protected while maintaining a smooth shopping experience.

Qstomy also offers a legal dashboard where each alert is categorized by severity level and linked to pre-drafted response templates adapted to different European jurisdictions. This automation reduces reaction time by an average of 70%, while ensuring documented compliance.

What checklist to follow before launching a product to avoid counterfeiting issues?

In short

Before going live, follow these steps:

FAQ

Q: What to do if a customer reports a counterfeit product? A: Remove it immediately, preserve evidence, and respond to the customer explaining the measures taken.

Q: Do I have to pay registration fees to the INPI for each brand? No, registration is mandatory but you only pay once per brand.

To go further: How to take an e-commerce brand from 0 to 7 figures? - Qstomy.

Finally, this final step ensures your catalog meets legal requirements before scaling up fully.

Enzo

October 31, 2026

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.