E-commerce
October 31, 2026
Wondering how to use comparative advertising without risking trademark violations?
In short, comparative advertising is allowed as long as it is truthful, non-misleading, and clearly identified as comparative.
The challenge lies in meeting clarity and transparency requirements, otherwise risking confusion and legal action for counterfeiting.
So, comparative advertising and brands? Here's the agenda:
What is comparative advertising?
What are the visible and invisible risks of trademark infringement?
How to write an honest and accurate comparison?
How Qstomy supports you in achieving compliance?
What checklist to apply before launching your campaign?
In addition to these points, we will cover best practices for layout, legal obligations specific to each jurisdiction, and automated tools that secure your marketing messages while maintaining a punchy tone. You will leave with a clear vision of the steps to follow to turn every comparison into a reliable and risk-free conversion lever.
Summary
What is comparative advertising?
Comparative advertising consists of presenting your product's features by contrasting them with those of a competitor. It informs consumers about differences in price, performance, or services. In France and the United States, competition authorities encourage this type of communication, provided it is truthful and not deceptive. The goal is to help customers make an informed choice while stimulating innovation among merchants.
This practice relies on the principle of free competition enshrined in the Consumer Code (Article L121-2) and, in the United States, on the principle of 'truth in advertising'. Legal references require that every claim be verifiable, that no element be confusing, and that the competitor's name be explicitly mentioned. In practice, this means the comparator must have documented data, such as official technical sheets or recognized market studies, to avoid any risk of defamation or counterfeiting.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.
The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion



Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants
What are the benefits for e‑merchants?
For a Shopify merchant, comparative advertising can increase conversion rates by highlighting unique assets: faster delivery, 24/7 customer service, or a simplified return policy. By leveraging data from SEO and Qstomy optimization tools, campaigns become more targeted and less costly. Moreover, clear comparisons reduce the number of returns, as expectations are aligned from the first click.
Thanks to the semantic analysis provided by Qstomy, you can identify the most relevant keywords for each compared criterion, which strengthens the organic visibility of your comparative pages. Structured tags (schema.org/Product) allow search engines to display rich snippets, thereby increasing the click-through rate (CTR). By combining these levers, you create a virtuous cycle where transparency improves trust, trust drives sales, and sales fund further advertising investments.
What are the legal requirements of the FTC (or the Competition Authority)?
In the United States, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) stipulates that comparative advertising must be: (i) true, (ii) not misleading, (iii) clearly identified as comparative. In Europe, the directive on unfair commercial practices imposes the same criteria. Any omission or misinterpretation can be sanctioned. Therefore, you must be able to justify every claim with a reliable source and clearly display the competitor's name to avoid ambiguity.
In France, Article L121‑8 of the Consumer Code specifies that comparisons must focus on essential characteristics of the product or service, and that information must be up to date. French case law, notably the rulings of the Court of Cassation on May 5, 2019, and January 27, 2021, has reiterated that even indirect comparisons (e.g., using a similar slogan) can constitute trademark infringement if they create a risk of confusion. Thus, every component of your message must be meticulously verified before publication.
How to distinguish between 'visible' and 'invisible' use of a trademark?
'Visible' use involves displaying the competitor's logo or name on the merchant's page, for example in a comparison table or a direct link. 'Invisible' use covers keywords, meta tags, or sponsored ads where the consumer does not see the brand, but the search engine triggers it based on it. Both categories are subject to distinct risk assessments regarding infringement.
This distinction has practical consequences: for visible use, written authorization from the trademark owner must be obtained whenever possible, or otherwise ensure that the display remains strictly descriptive. For invisible use, advertising platforms often impose additional rules, such as limited geographic targeting or prohibitions on using registered trademarks in ad titles. Qstomy automatically analyzes every link, image, and metadata to identify the type of use and propose necessary adjustments.
What are the risks of trademark infringement in visible advertising?
When a merchant places a competitor's logo in a banner or comparison table, they risk an accusation of counterfeiting if the use creates confusion regarding the origin of the product. The court will evaluate the distinctiveness of the sign, the context of presentation, and the risk of confusion. An explicit mention of the comparative nature and the absence of suggestive elements of affiliation are essential for protection.
French case law has produced several landmark rulings, including the Paris Court of Appeal ruling of March 12, 2022, which determined that using a logo in a comparison table is lawful provided the text clearly states that it is a comparison and not an affiliation. Furthermore, adding an 'impartial opinion' or a footnote explaining the comparison methodology strengthens the defense against counterfeiting accusations. Thus, every visual must be accompanied by descriptive text that neutralizes the risk of confusion.
What are the risks of trademark infringement in invisible advertising (keywords, PPC)?
Purchasing keywords containing a competitor's name (pay-per-click) can generate the phenomenon of 'initial interest confusion.' If the ad appears before the consumer realizes it is from a third party, the risk of confusion is high. US courts (9th Circuit) apply a three-step test: similarity of signs, connection between products, and simultaneous use of online channels. In France, case law requires reasonable necessity and the absence of any implication of a partnership.
Famous cases like 'Google Shopping v. Apple' (2015) show that simply including a brand name in a search query can be deemed abusive if the ad does not clearly specify the seller's identity. In Europe, the Court of Justice of the European Union ruling of February 14, 2020, reiterated that simply using a keyword identical to a registered trademark is not automatically prohibited, but the ad text must include a clear statement of non-association. Qstomy verifies these requirements in real-time and provides tailored wording recommendations.
How to write an honest and accurate comparison?
The key to compliance lies in the precision of facts. Every data point (weight, capacity, price, warranty) must be verifiable and comparable. If a criterion is relevant, it must be mentioned; if not, it must be omitted. A short accompanying text, accessible in one click, must specify sources and any exclusions. This transparency prevents competitors from challenging the ad for omission or bias.
To ensure this accuracy, it is advisable to use a double validation process: an initial internal check (by the product team) followed by legal validation. Using automation tools, such as Qstomy's fact-checker, allows comparing each figure against public databases (INPI, EU databases, price registries). Finally, adding a downloadable comparison table in PDF format with a timestamp strengthens credibility with consumers and authorities.
What specific elements should accompany the comparison?
In addition to figures, it is recommended to add:
Conditions de vente : delivery times, shipping costs, etc.
Sources : links to the competitor's product pages (nom de domaine).
Legal notices : comparative advertising, clearly visible disclaimer.
It is also recommended to use visual icons (checkmarks, stars) to indicate criteria met by your product and those of the competitor. A responsive table that adapts to mobile screens avoids distortions that could make the comparison difficult to read. Finally, consider including an 'Learn More' button that redirects to a detailed page containing case studies, expert reviews, and independent performance data to enhance transparency and trust.
When should the comparative nature be clearly declared?
The comparative nature must be visible at first glance. A banner: 'Comparison with [Competitor Name]', or a 'Comparative Advertising' logo placed at the top of the section is sufficient. The mention must not be hidden in the footer. If the ad appears in a sponsored feed, the label 'Comparative Ad' is mandatory to avoid ambiguity.
For better readability, use a contrasting font and a background color that stands out from the rest of the page. The text should be written in simple language, avoiding legal abbreviations that could obscure the message. On mobile devices, a sticky banner ensures the mention remains visible even during scrolling. Finally, consider testing visibility with accessibility tools (WCAG) to confirm that screen readers correctly announce the page's comparative status.
What possible sanctions exist in case of confusion or misleading advertising?
Sanctions vary by jurisdiction. In France, the Competition Authority can impose fines up to 10% of annual turnover, in addition to damages for the trademark holder. In the United States, the FTC can order the removal of ads, impose fines, and even pursue legal action. Reputational risk is also significant: loss of customer trust and a drop in conversion rates.
In Europe, Directive 2005/29/EC provides for administrative sanctions up to 2% of the company's global turnover, as well as injunction measures requiring the correction of faulty messages within a set deadline. Additionally, courts may order the publication of a corrective press release, which directly impacts brand credibility. It is therefore crucial to implement preventive controls to avoid these financial and reputational costs.
How does Qstomy help ensure your comparative advertising is compliant?
Qstomy, your AI assistant dedicated to Shopify, analyzes each advertising text to detect counterfeiting risks. It offers:
Truth verification : it compares your claims against public databases and suggests reliable sources.
Brand usage alerts : it flags every occurrence of a competitor's name or logo and indicates whether it is visible or invisible usage.
Disclaimer templates : it automatically generates the legal text 'Comparative Advertising' compliant with FTC and EU requirements.
In addition to these basic features, Qstomy offers a compliance dashboard that centralizes alerts, improvement suggestions, and validation histories. You can configure custom tolerance thresholds, receive email notifications before going live, and even export an audit report for your legal department. Everything integrates directly into the Shopify interface without the need for an additional plugin.
What checklist to follow before launching a comparative campaign?
As a reminder, here are the steps to validate:
Verify accuracy : each piece of data must be supported by a reliable source.
Identifier l’usage : visible or invisible? Adapt the text accordingly.
Include a disclaimer : label 'Comparative Advertisement' at the top of the page.
Add reference links : redirect to the competitor's product pages or to your own blog (optimisation SEO).
Submit to Qstomy : let the AI check compliance before going live.
To go further: How to create a payment gateway for an e-commerce site? - Qstomy, How to handle customer questions mixing multiple languages in a conversation - Qstomy, How to Handle Customer Questions About an Offer Seen in Offline Advertising - Qstomy, How to handle customer questions about web offers not available in-store - Qstomy. Bonus : download our free compliance charter template by clicking here.

Enzo
October 31, 2026


