E-commerce
October 31, 2026
Are you wondering how to identify and prevent online fraud?
The essentials: analyze each order, cross-reference payment data, and apply targeted controls; this is the best protection.
The challenge lies in the variety of fraudulent techniques and the risk of losing legitimate sales if you are too strict.
Additionally, automating these checks using tools like Qstomy saves time, improves ROI, and reduces human errors, while maintaining a smooth shopping experience.
Alors How to identify and prevent online fraud? In this guide:
What are the first indicators to monitor?
How to use the security code and AVS?
Which shipping and address methods raise the most alarms?
How to verify a customer's legitimacy via email and phone?
What role does Qstomy play in detection and prevention?
Let's go.
By adopting a risk score-based approach and combining artificial intelligence with human validation, you create a dynamic barrier that adapts to new fraud methods.
Summary
What are the first indicators to monitor?
The first filter lies in the information you receive from the payment processor: the Card Security Code (CSC) and the Address Verification System (AVS). If the entered CSC does not match the one printed on the card, immediately reject the order. However, a correct CSC is not a guarantee, as a fraudster in physical possession of the card may know it. The AVS returns two responses: one for the street number and one for the zip code. They are displayed as 'Y' (yes) or 'N' (no). Do not rely solely on the AVS; consider it as one element among others in your risk score.
In addition, keep a history of each rejection to identify recurring patterns and adjust your thresholds based on the evolving behavior of fraudsters. This periodic analysis allows you to reduce false positives while maintaining effective protection.
Finally, remember to regularly test your process with simulated transactions to identify any potential weak points.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.
The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion



Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants
How to leverage the CSC and AVS?
Integrate the CSC and AVS into your Shopify process via your payment gateway settings. Program a rule that automatically blocks transactions where the CSC is missing or invalid. For the AVS, create a threshold: if both responses are 'Y', authorize the order; if either is 'N', increase the risk score and trigger a manual review. Combine this data with customer information (address, zip, country) and you will obtain a robust first layer of defense without impacting the shopping experience.
Also consider synchronizing these rules with your Qstomy dashboard so that every anomaly is immediately logged and you can refine parameters in real time based on feedback.
A monthly update of these rules ensures that new gateway requirements remain accounted for.
Which shipping and address methods raise the most alarms?
Fraudsters often favor fast shipping to obtain goods before the card is cancelled. A high ratio between shipping cost and product value (e.g., €60 shipping for a €30 item) should catch your attention. Additionally, a shipping address different from the billing address, especially when located in another country, is a classic alarm signal. Use an IP geolocation tool to compare the device location with the billing country. If the inconsistency persists, review the order or request additional confirmation. To learn more about managing a offre web uniquement, consult our dedicated guide.
In practice, you can set a shipping cost threshold beyond which the order is automatically put on hold, while offering the legitimate customer the option to choose a more standard shipping method.
Also monitor spikes in orders from the same IP address, as this may indicate a fraud network.
How to verify a customer's legitimacy via email and phone?
A valid and responsive email is often the first sign of trust. Send a small confirmation message: if the customer replies quickly, you have a good clue. Be wary of addresses from unknown free services or domains like .edu, .mil, or .gov, which, although rare, are generally more reliable. For phone numbers, use a geolocation API to verify that the prefix matches the billing address. If in doubt, call the customer; a short conversation can reveal many inconsistencies.
Adding a two-step email verification field (double opt-in) strengthens security and gives you an additional record to examine in case of disputes.
Use a real-time email verification service to detect disposable domains at the time of entry.
Which geographic areas should be monitored closely?
Certain regions are historically more exposed to fraud: Nigeria, Russia, Bulgaria, etc. If a shipping address points to one of these destinations, immediately increase the risk score. Remember that fraudsters often use forwarding services to mask the true origin. A best practice is to block direct shipments to high-risk countries unless you have additional validation (ID photo, proof of residence). You can consult best practices in our article on member-exclusive offers.
Additionally, use a regularly updated database of risky addresses; this allows you to react quickly to new geographical fraud trends.
Integrate a dynamic blacklist that updates via feedback from anti-fraud platforms.
How to use online address verification services?
APIs like the one presented in gift‑card + paiement carte allow you to confirm the existence of an address or phone number. Integrate these services into your checkout process: if the result indicates a non-existent address or an unassigned phone number, flag the order as suspicious. This step adds to CSC/AVS checks and strengthens your risk score without slowing down the customer journey.
Remember to store the result of each verification in the customer profile to have a complete history that can be reused for future transactions.
Keep API responses in an encrypted log so they can be presented during a dispute.
How to request additional proof without alienating the customer?
When the risk is high, clearly explain to the customer that you must verify their identity to protect their account. Offer to upload, via the customer dashboard, a photo of the credit card (masking the last 4 digits) or a passport. Most legitimate buyers understand the process and cooperate. Create a simple upload form in Shopify, then automate the follow-up email using Qstomy, which centralizes attachments and notifies you upon receipt. You will find a sample text in Integrate customer service responses into an SEO strategy.
Always offer an alternative payment method (e.g., PayPal or bank transfer) if the customer prefers not to share sensitive documents, so you do not lose legitimate sales.
Ensure the upload form is GDPR-compliant by encrypting files immediately upon upload.
What role does Qstomy play in fraud prevention?
Qstomy acts as a dedicated AI assistant for your Shopify store. It analyzes each order in real-time, cross-referencing CSC, AVS, IP geolocation, and customer history data. When a risk score exceeds the defined threshold, Qstomy automatically suggests an action: manual validation, document request, or blocking. It also generates personalized verification emails and logs every decision in the dashboard, facilitating audits. Furthermore, Qstomy synchronizes with your support pages (Politique de support e‑commerce) to ensure customer responses remain consistent.
Thanks to its daily reports, you can track fraud trends, identify the most frequent vectors, and proactively adjust your filtering rules.
Qstomy dashboards also offer predictive alerts based on the history of fraud attempts.
How to automate the review of high-risk orders?
If transaction volume exceeds your capacity to examine them manually, invest in a scoring software or hire a developer to create a Shopify script. This script will assign a score based on CSC, AVS, country, shipping method, and customer history. Orders above the threshold are placed in a 'To Verify' queue where Qstomy proposes concrete actions. You can also configure Slack or email alerts so you never miss a potential fraud. For specific advice on international management, consult notre guide support international.
By integrating an interactive dashboard, you can visualize in real-time the number of risky orders, the verification conversion rate, and the savings achieved through prevention.
The script can also trigger a webhook to your CRM to automatically create a support ticket.
What communication best practices should be adopted with suspicious customers?
Transparent communication reduces abandonment rates. Inform the customer that verification aims to protect their purchase and data. Use Qstomy templates to send a short, professional email (Integrate customer service responses into an SEO strategy). Offer an alternative payment method or an extended delivery timeframe if the customer agrees to provide proof. By being proactive, you will turn a potential risk into a positive customer experience.
Do not forget to include a link to your privacy policy to reassure the customer about the handling of their personal data.
Enhance messages with the verification tracking number to reassure the customer about traceability.
How does Qstomy simplify the management of fraudulent returns?
When you detect a suspicious return (e.g., a tracking number that does not match the billing address), Qstomy alerts you immediately. It triggers a verification procedure: request for proof of purchase, identity confirmation, or suspension of the refund until validation. The Qstomy dashboard logs every step, simplifying audits and reducing losses. Additionally, by linking the process to your support policy (On-demand manufacturing lead times), you ensure full compliance.
Furthermore, you can set a waiting period before refunding for high-risk cases, limiting abuse while remaining compliant with local legislation.
What checklist to apply before each shipment?
Anti-fraud checklist before shipping
Check the CSC : correspondance obligatoire.
Analyser l’AVS : Y/Y, Y/N, N/Y, or N/N; adjust the score.
Compare billing and shipping addresses ; look for geographical discrepancies.
Check the shipping method ; avoid ultra-fast deliveries for high-risk orders.
Validate email and phone ; send a confirmation email.
Use geolocation APIs ; compare the customer's IP to the billing country.
FAQ express
Should I always block an order with a negative AVS? No, use it as a risk factor, not as an absolute criterion.
What is the best score threshold? Start at 70% and adjust based on your false positive rate.
Can Qstomy handle fraudulent returns? Yes, it creates alerts and logs every action.
By applying this checklist, you limit losses and offer a secure shopping experience.
Regularly update your scoring parameters based on newly detected threats, and train your support team on verification best practices to ensure continuous defense.

Enzo
October 31, 2026


