E-commerce
October 29, 2026
Are you wondering how to analyze five e-commerce email subject lines to increase your open rates?
By studying the subjects used by brands like MyHabit, GAP, or Overstock, you can identify best practices and pitfalls to avoid.
Each subject line has its specifics: length, tone, discount promise, or intriguing question. Knowing how to break them down helps you avoid common traps and craft impactful subjects.
In addition to simple observation, it is essential to systematically test each variant on a representative sample, then analyze the feedback using Qstomy metrics. This iterative approach allows you to progressively refine your subject lines based on actual subscriber behavior.
So how to analyze 5 e-commerce email subject lines to boost your open rates? On the agenda:
What are the strengths and limitations of the MyHabit subject?
Why might the GAP subject 'What humidity?' be confusing?
How does the Overstock subject combine multiple offers without losing clarity?
What impact does the use of uppercase letters have in the Cost Plus World Market subject?
What is the ideal length for a subject line according to best practices?
Let's go.
Summary
What are the strengths and limitations of the MyHabit subject?
MyHabit chose a very dense subject: « Up to 70% off: Designer Shoes & Accessories | Up to 80% Off: Designer Sportswear | Just $30: Nat Nast Swimwear… ». The strength lies in the clarity of the offer; each benefit is quantified, immediately grabbing attention. By displaying percentages and prices, the email promises a concrete gain. However, the length (150 characters) far exceeds the recommended 40‑50 characters, risking truncation on mobile devices or in certain email clients. Some recipients see only the first part and miss the other promotions. Ideally, these offers should be segmented: a dedicated email for shoes, another for swimwear, to keep the subject line short and targeted. Additionally, testing two variants—a highly condensed version and a detailed one—will allow you to measure which level of granularity generates the best open rate for each segment.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.
The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion



Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants
Why might the « What humidity? » subject from GAP confuse recipients?
You have likely noticed that the GAP subject is limited to two words: « What humidity? ». This approach is intriguing, but it does not reflect the actual content of the email, which begins with a 25% discount. The main issue is the lack of alignment: the reader expects an answer to a climate question, but finds a commercial offer. This dissonance can increase unsubscribe rates or spam reports. Moreover, the question does not target the interests of most subscribers, except those living in a region where humidity is a current topic. A better practice would have been to combine curiosity with the value proposition, for example: « What look to adopt with 25% off when it's hot? ». You could also add a personalization element (« Paris, enjoy 25% off ») to enhance relevance and reduce the risk of confusion.
How does the Overstock subject combine multiple offers without losing clarity?
Overstock opted for a long but structured subject: « Extra 10% off Select Bedding & Bath, Home Decor, Garden & Patio and More! ». The strength of this subject lies in the progressive enumeration of categories; the reader knows immediately what to expect. Each segment of the text corresponds to a part of the email body, creating visual coherence. Nevertheless, the message remains quite voluminous (73 characters) and may be truncated on small screens. The real weakness appears when the list becomes too long: the reader may feel overwhelmed and fail to identify the main offer. An effective strategy is to test two versions: a short version focused on the flagship category (e.g., « 30% off bedding ») and a long version for the most engaged subscribers. Adding an emoji « 🛏️ » at the beginning of the short subject can also increase the open rate without weighing down the text.
What impact does the use of uppercase letters have in the Cost Plus World Market subject?
Cost Plus World Market highlighted the message « LAST CHANCE , up to 50% off select Furniture, Throw Pillows and Lighting » entirely in uppercase. The advantage is instant: the text jumps out, creates a sense of urgency, and encourages action. However, spam filters from many ESPs (Mailchimp, SendinBlue…) often flag uppercase titles as potential spam, especially when they contain promotional terms (« off », « sale »). Moreover, excessive use of uppercase can fatigue the reader and give the impression of shouting. A good practice is to use uppercase only for the first word or the key term (« Last chance ») and leave the rest in sentence case, while maintaining the urgent feel with an emoji like 🕒 (if allowed) or words like « last », « urgent ». Also consider harmonizing the tone with your brand voice: if your brand is warmer, prefer a more conversational style (« Last chance, enjoy 50% off ») to avoid the perception of aggression.
What is the ideal length for a subject line according to best practices?
Platform studies like Mailchimp indicate that the optimal length is between 35 and 50 characters, including spaces. Below 30 characters, the subject may lack sufficient information to spark interest. Above 70 characters, the text is often truncated on mobile devices and in webmail preview panes. The golden rule is therefore to aim for a balance: include a clear benefit (e.g., "‑30%", "new arrivals") while remaining concise. Use powerful words, avoid unnecessary filler, and systematically test subject visibility across major clients (Gmail, Outlook, Apple Mail). A good test involves sending the email to an internal address and checking the rendering on smartphones and computers. Remember to measure the impact of each length variation on the open rate to identify the sweet spot specific to your audience.
How to personalize a subject line to increase relevance for the reader?
Personalization goes far beyond the first name. By using past purchase data, location, or interest segments, you can create a subject that speaks directly to the recipient. For example, "Marie, your new handbag has arrived" or "Paris: 20% off summer t-shirts". With Qstomy, you have access to order histories and customer preferences, making it easy to generate dynamic subjects via our interface. Don't forget to test relevance: a subject that is too specific can seem intrusive, while one that is too generic loses impact. Always include a clear benefit and an implicit call to action to maximize the open rate. Also, ensure compliance with data protection rules: do not overload the recipient with overly personal information without explicit consent.
Which A/B tests to run to choose between a short and a detailed subject?
An A/B test involves sending two variants of the same campaign to similar segments of your list. Variant A: short subject (35 characters) highlighting the main benefit. Variant B: longer subject (70 characters) listing multiple offers. Measure the open rate, click-through rate, and revenue generated. With Qstomy, you can automatically create two test groups and track real-time metrics via our dashboard. Once the winning version is identified, apply it to your entire base. Don't forget to control external variables (send time, day of the week) so the result is truly attributable to the subject. Also ensure you reach a statistically significant sample size (at least 1% of your list) so the conclusions are reliable.
How to segment your list to tailor the subject to specific interests?
Segmentation is based on purchase behavior, interaction frequency, and location. For example, customers who have bought sports items are more sensitive to a subject like "30% off running equipment". Those who have never opened your newsletters might receive a re-engagement subject ("Miss us? Discover 15% off"). Qstomy allows you to create dynamic segments in a few clicks: filter by purchase category, average order value, or recent activity. Once segmented, create tailored subject lines for each group to increase relevance and, consequently, the open rate. Additionally, remember to regularly refresh your segmentation criteria to account for seasonal changes and new shopping trends.
Why avoid certain spam-triggering words and which terms to prioritize?
Anti-spam filters scan for words like "free", "percent off", "sale", or "help". Their excessive presence increases the risk of being classified as spam, especially when they appear in uppercase. Prefer natural phrasing: "Special Offer", "Exclusive Discount", "Take advantage of our new arrivals". Use action verbs ("Discover", "Save") and limit punctuation symbols ("!", "%") to one per subject. By combining these best practices with deliverability rates monitored via Qstomy, you maintain a solid sender reputation. Also consider adapting your phrasing to the languages of your various audiences: a term that works in French may trigger a filter in English, hence the importance of careful localization.
How to measure the effectiveness of a subject line after sending?
After sending, track three essential KPIs: open rate, click-through rate, and conversion rate. The open rate indicates subject attractiveness, the click-through rate measures content engagement, and the conversion rate shows impact on sales. Qstomy automatically collects these metrics and provides comparative charts between A/B variants. Also analyze deliverability (bounce rate) and unsubscribe rate, as an overly aggressive subject can generate unsubscribes. By cross-referencing these data points, you identify the formulations that work best for your audience. To go further, leverage click heatmaps and user journey maps to understand how the subject influences post-open behavior.
How does Qstomy help create and test high-performing email subject lines?
Qstomy integrates a subject line generator based on purchase history and customer preferences. You select your segment, define the tone (promotions, new arrivals, urgency), and the tool proposes three optimized variants. Thanks to our dashboard, you can immediately launch an A/B test, view open rates in real-time, and apply the winning variant to your entire list. Additionally, Qstomy monitors deliverability and alerts you to suspicious behavior (spam, high bounce proportion). This automation saves time while increasing the relevance of each campaign. Native integration with major CRMs (Salesforce, HubSpot) allows you to synchronize customer data and further enrich subject personalization.
What is a quick checklist before sending your next email campaign?
In short
Objet court ? Ensure it does not exceed 50 characters.
Personnalisation ? Insert the first name or a purchase criterion.
Test A/B ? Schedule two variants and define the success criterion.
Deliverability? Confirm that the bounce rate is below 2%.
Segment ? Select the most relevant target group.
Heure d’envoi ? Test different time slots (morning, noon, evening) to identify when your audience is most responsive.
FAQ
Should I always include a discount percentage? Yes, but avoid using the words 'percent off' in all caps.
What is the best day to send an email? Test Tuesday and Thursday; these are often the days with the highest open rates.
Can Qstomy automate A/B testing? Absolutely, it creates the variants, sends them, and compiles the results.
To go further: How to improve conversion rates for e-commerce sales? - Qstomy, How to improve e-commerce conversion rates and sales? - Qstomy, How to deploy digital marketing on an e-commerce site? - Qstomy, How to increase e-commerce store sales? - Qstomy, How to handle customer inquiries about lost carts after device changes - Qstomy, How to handle customer inquiries about member-exclusive sales - Qstomy, How to handle customer inquiries about missing accessories in the package - Qstomy.

Enzo
October 29, 2026


