E-commerce
October 30, 2026
Are you wondering how to navigate between official rules and tacit practices on marketplaces?
In short, mastering these two dimensions helps you avoid account suspensions, lost sales, and conflicts with competitors.
Platforms display clear policies, but support teams often apply unannounced criteria that influence the outcome of disputes.
It is therefore crucial to maintain continuous legal monitoring to anticipate policy updates and keep room for maneuver.
So, what formal and informal rules must you know to succeed on marketplaces? On the agenda: By staying informed about updates and adapting your strategy, you turn constraints into opportunities for sustainable growth.
What are the written rules of marketplaces like Amazon and eBay?
What informal behaviors do customer service teams apply?
Why does relying solely on a marketplace put your business at risk?
How does Amazon manage product listings and what challenges does this create?
What risks does creating duplicate listings on Amazon pose?
Let's go.
Summary
What are the written rules of marketplaces like Amazon and eBay?
Each marketplace publishes a set of policies regarding registration, pricing, product compliance, and customer service. On Amazon, the Guide marketing digital reminds sellers that they must respect the unique catalog, provide compliant images, and declare the exact GTIN code. eBay, for its part, imposes honest descriptions, prohibits deceptive practices, and requires respect for intellectual property rights. Ignoring a clause, for example, a wrong product category, can lead to immediate suspension. The first step is therefore to carefully read the terms of use and integrate them into your SOP (Standard Operating Procedures). In addition, meeting these requirements improves the internal search ranking of your listings and increases your chances of winning the Buy Box. Furthermore, regularly monitoring customer reviews helps you quickly detect any non-compliance and correct errors before they lead to suspension.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.
The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion



Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants
What informal behaviors do customer service teams apply?
Beyond the legal text, support agents evaluate each dispute based on unpublished criteria: seller history, frequency of complaints, and even the tone of the message. For example, a merchant with several positive reviews will often be favored, while a profile frequently reported will see their requests rejected more quickly. These informal practices are sometimes called the 'unwritten rules'. Anticipating these expectations means maintaining impeccable service quality, responding quickly to messages, and documenting every exchange with evidence (photos, invoices). Thus, you reduce the risk of a discreet unfavorable decision. The average response time and the level of agent training are also invisible levers to monitor. Moreover, maintain a detailed history of every exchange in your CRM so you can present it in case of a dispute.
Why does relying solely on a marketplace put your business at risk?
Entrusting 100% of your revenue to a platform exposes your business to a major vulnerability: account suspension or deactivation without notice. Once the account is blocked, you lose not only ongoing sales but also access to your customer data, ratings, and reputation. The most common scenario is a complaint from a competitor or a customer that triggers an automated audit. The solution is to diversify your channels, your own website, social media, secondary marketplaces, and to systematically collect buyers' email addresses to re-engage them via your Shopify store. A business continuity plan and prudent cash flow management help limit the impact on cash flow during a suspension. Furthermore, implementing a backup system for your product data ensures you can quickly reimport your listings in case of a purge.
How does Amazon manage product listings and what challenges does this create?
Amazon imposes a fiche unique per product: each ASIN groups all offers. The seller must enter their price, stock, and barcode, but cannot create a separate listing. This centralization favors comparison but opens the door to positioning games. If your offer does not appear at the top, competitors may attempt to create a "fake" variant by modifying the barcode or description. Amazon has a duplicate merging process, but it is often slow. Therefore, the seller must monitor their ASIN daily, report duplications, and keep proof of authenticity readily available. Amazon's quality control, which verifies image and information compliance, directly influences eligibility for the Buy Box. It is also recommended to periodically test your offer's visibility via anonymous searches to detect potential blocks.
What risks does creating duplicate listings on Amazon pose?
Duplicate listings fragment rankings and dilute customer reviews. A competitor may intentionally introduce a variant with a different barcode to push your product lower in the rankings. If the marketplace deems the new barcode illegitimate, it may suspend both offers until validation. The seller is then left without visibility and with blocked stock. To prevent this, it is recommended to verify that each product has the official GTIN, declare the same ASIN as your competitors, and use the SEO for e‑commerce to optimize your listing content and improve your ranking naturally. In case of suspension, the Seller Performance center allows you to file an appeal with documented evidence. Finally, upon the first duplication alert, immediately contact Seller Support with your evidence on hand to expedite processing.
How to react to pressure or threats from a competitor on a marketplace?
When you receive an intimidating message (e.g., "remove your offer within 24 hours", "I will file a complaint"), save all emails and screenshots. First, verify that your listing meets requirements (photos, description, barcode). If everything is in order, respond calmly by presenting your evidence and citing the written rules. In case of escalation, use the marketplace's official channel (e.g., Amazon's internal messaging system) so agents can review the dispute. If the competitor persists, report the abusive behavior via the harassment reporting form; this creates a history that support can leverage. Also log chat transcripts and timestamps to have a reliable judicial record. If no satisfactory response is obtained, you can escalate the dispute to the marketplace's compliance department.
What are the best practices to prove your offer complies with the rules?
Documentary evidence is your best ally. Keep purchase invoices, shipping manifests, photos of the product in its original packaging, and the visible barcode. Centralize these items in a shared folder (e.g., Google Drive) and create a tracking table for ASINs, GTINs, and listing dates. During a dispute, quickly share the link to this folder along with a clear summary. In parallel, keep your politique de support so your customers know your return and claim procedures, which reduces the number of conflicting tickets. Automated document management tools, such as DAMs, facilitate the immediate retrieval of each requested proof. Also use automatic timestamps for each document to prove the chronology in case of disagreement.
How to report a duplication or non-compliance issue to the platform?
Amazon offers a dedicated 'Report a Violation' form. You must specify the ASIN in question, the nature of the issue (duplication, incorrect barcode, non-compliant description), and attach your evidence. The same principle applies to eBay via the 'Report a Listing Issue' help center. After submission, monitor your internal inbox; agents may request additional information. Generally, a 48-hour timeframe is indicated, but follow-ups are sometimes necessary. During this time, keep your offer active to avoid lost sales, but limit purchases until resolution if the risk of suspension is high. Keep the ticket reference number and use it for any escalation or follow-up with support. Keep a copy of each submitted form to maintain a complete audit trail if needed.
What practices help limit account suspensions and stock blocks?
Adopt a proactive approach: check compliance alerts daily, update your descriptions as soon as requirements change, and limit fraudulent returns by verifying tracking number validity. Use analysis tools from conversation analytics to identify recurring complaint patterns and adjust your service. Finally, set a minimum stock alert on your Shopify dashboard to never run out of a product sold on a marketplace, which would automatically trigger a suspension of the offer. A dedicated KPI dashboard for compliance allows you to visualize critical indicators in real time. A monthly review of compliance KPIs allows you to anticipate deviations before they become critical.
How to optimize your visibility while staying within imposed limits?
Internal marketplace SEO is key. Use relevant keywords in the product title, short description, and key features, while respecting length restrictions. Complete the listing with high-resolution images, videos, and clear bullet points. On Amazon, the program Buy Box favors sellers with fast shipping rates, low defect rates, and competitive pricing. On eBay, sponsored listings allow you to gain visibility, provided you adhere to floor price rules. Combine these actions with a strategy of optimisation SEO on your own store to recover organic traffic. Enhance your listings with A+ content and test different titles through A/B experiments to maximize conversion. Regularly test title and description variations through A/B experiments to identify what maximizes the conversion rate.
How Qstomy helps you manage these constraints and secure your sales?
Qstomy acts as your dedicated AI assistant for Shopify. It centralizes compliance alerts from marketplaces, proposes corrective actions (barcode updates, description rewrites), and automatically generates proof documents to attach to disputes. Additionally, Qstomy optimizes the checkout funnel: product recommendations, upsell/cross-sell, real-time order tracking, and customer service management via a smart chatbot. This allows you to maintain control over your customer relationships while meeting each platform's requirements. With a single dashboard, you see your Marketplace sales, Shopify inventory, and quality metrics, minimizing suspension risks and maximizing revenue. Native integration with your ERP ensures instant synchronization of inventory and prices across all channels. Thanks to AI, Qstomy also suggests real-time pricing adjustments to stay competitive while respecting imposed price thresholds.
What checklist to follow before launching a product on a marketplace?
In short
Verify GTIN : official barcode, matching with ASIN.
Visual compliance : clear photos, adherence to size requirements.
Texte d’offre : accurate description, authorized keywords.
Preuve d’achat : facture fournisseur, bordereau de livraison.
Pricing strategy : analyse concurrentielle, marge suffisante.
Plan de suivi : alerts stock, notifications de litige.
Legal compliance test : check local obligations (REACH, CE) before launch.
Continuity plan : prepare migration and business recovery procedures in case of sudden suspension.
FAQ
Can marketplaces suspend my account without explanation? Yes, but by keeping evidence you can contest quickly.
How to avoid duplicate listings? Use the official GTIN and report any suspicious variants.
What role does Qstomy play in customer service management? It provides automated responses, tracks tickets, and feeds your SEO knowledge bases.
What is the best way to prepare a continuity plan? Document your data flows, automate backups, and set up backup contacts to react quickly.
To go further: Can you sell Amazon products on Shopify? - Qstomy, Integrating CS responses into a useful e-commerce SEO strategy for customers - Qstomy.

Enzo
October 30, 2026


