E-commerce
October 31, 2026
Wondering how to avoid pitfalls and replicate the success of a seasoned marketing director?
Cathy McManus, who leads marketing at Stacks, shares her best practices: choosing the right partners, mastering costs, and placing the customer at the heart of the strategy.
Her journey shows that every decision, from the server to the advertising platform, impacts profitability. Some tools promise gold but deliver only hidden costs.
So what lessons did Cathy McManus of Stacks learn from her e-commerce marketing experience? On the agenda:
How to select third-party vendors without blowing the budget?
What type of software cart suits young brands?
How to ensure reliable and scalable hosting?
How to build an agile team with freelancers?
Why can PPC campaigns be counterproductive?
In addition to these points, we will explore how to measure the real impact of new technologies, how to turn customer feedback into optimization opportunities, and how to build a data-driven culture that supports long-term growth. Let's go.
You will also discover how to turn every friction point into an innovation opportunity, thanks to iterative processes and data-driven analysis.
Summary
How to choose third-party vendors that truly add value?
Stacks started by developing its own tools, then outsourced as soon as a more robust solution was available. Cathy recommends waiting until sales volume justifies the investment to avoid underutilized licenses.
Elle utilise aujourd’hui Celebros for internal search, Certona for recommendations and Google Analytics for tracking. The idea is to keep only services that concretely improve the customer experience and remain affordable.
Before adopting a new SaaS, test it for free, measure its impact on average order value, and only validate if ROI becomes visible in less than three months.
An additional criterion Cathy highlights is compatibility with other tools already in place: a vendor requiring a complete process overhaul will cost far more than expected. Thus, prioritize solutions with open APIs that integrate naturally into your technical stack and avoid data silos.
Finally, regularly monitor engagement metrics to ensure each integration continues to deliver measurable long-term value.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.
The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion



Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants
What type of software cart is ideal for new Shopify merchants?
Stacks has a proprietary cart, but Cathy emphasizes that 'off-the-shelf' solutions are perfectly suited for beginners. They offer secure updates, compatibility with Shopify extensions, and dedicated technical support.
For a store just starting, a ready-to-use cart allows you to focus on the product rather than code. You can then migrate to a custom solution when traffic justifies the investment.
In parallel, Qstomy offers recommendations for cart applications that integrate in one click, minimizing downtime and plugin conflicts.
Cathy also recommends checking multilingual checkout options and localized payment modules from the start to avoid having to redeploy a new cart when expanding into new geographic markets.
Also take time to test checkout speed on various mobile devices to ensure a seamless experience for all users.
How to ensure reliable and scalable hosting for your store?
Stacks initially shared a server with Verio, then migrated to a dedicated server when load caused slowdowns. Cathy advises choosing a host that offers a dedicated manager: without this, your store becomes just a cog in the support chain.
A dedicated server offers resource isolation, faster load times, and more control over security configurations.
On Shopify, the infrastructure is already optimized, but it is essential to use a plan suited to your traffic volume. Qstomy helps monitor performance and adjust the plan in real time.
In addition to capacity, consider geographic redundancy: a host offering multiple data centers protects you against local outages and improves response times for international visitors.
Additionally, enable availability alerts to be notified instantly in case of response time degradation.
How to build an agile team with freelancers and students?
Cathy does not believe in a magic number of employees. She prefers freelance writers and part-time students, who bring creativity and flexibility at a lower cost.
Universities are excellent sources of motivated talent. By offering occasional projects, you benefit from fresh ideas while keeping your labor budget in check.
To ensure brand tone consistency, Qstomy centralizes briefs and deliverables via its content management system, ensuring simplified tracking.
Another lever Cathy uses is establishing an internal mentorship program, where more experienced freelancers guide students. This creates a continuous learning dynamic, reduces turnover, and strengthens deliverable quality.
This method maintains consistent quality while leveraging the diversity of creative perspectives brought by young talent.
Why might pay-per-click campaigns not be profitable for some stores?
Stacks tested several PPC agencies, but the return on investment was insufficient. Cathy explains that without an internal team to optimize ads, cost per click does not translate into conversions.
She prefers measuring cost per acquisition (CPA) rather than just the number of clicks. If CPA exceeds average revenue per order, the strategy needs rethinking.
Qstomy offers a dashboard that automatically calculates CPA by channel, allowing you to adjust budgets based on actual performance.
Additionally, she recommends running A/B tests on creatives and landing pages before scaling spend, to quickly identify the most profitable audience segments and avoid budget waste.
Do not forget to analyze return on investment by device (mobile vs desktop) to reallocate budgets toward the most performing channels.
How to optimize SEO when a site redesign causes a traffic drop?
After a redesign, Stacks saw its traffic drop, which led it to engage WPromote. The lesson: every change must be accompanied by pre- and post-update SEO analysis.
Cathy set up product blogs and a main blog (Cluttercontrolfreak.com) to strengthen domain authority. Content must be consistent, regularly updated, and optimized for targeted keywords.
Qstomy directly integrates SEO recommendations into the product page creation process, flagging missing tags and internal linking opportunities.
An audit of URL structure and 301 redirects before going live prevents unexpected SEO juice loss.
How to avoid over-investing in overly sophisticated software for an SME?
Cathy notes that overly complex software solutions often require dedicated teams for management, which is not cost-effective for small and medium-sized enterprises. She recommends choosing simple, scalable tools that integrate naturally into your existing stack.
Before purchasing, ask yourself about ROI: does the software reduce operational costs or increase average order value? If the answer is no, wait for a lightweight version or a complementary module.
Qstomy offers a library of pre-validated applications, categorized by business impact, to quickly choose the most profitable solutions.
Prefer SaaS solutions with a usage-based pricing model to keep costs under control during the growth phase.
What are the best practices for accounting and order management?
Stacks utilise MAS 500 Sage for accounting, coupled with a proprietary order management system that will soon be integrated into the ERP. Cathy emphasizes the importance of real-time synchronization between sales and accounting to avoid discrepancies.
Linking each order to an automated invoice number reduces bank reconciliation errors and facilitates audits.
With Qstomy, you can connect your Shopify store to Sage or other ERPs via secure data flows, ensuring flawless accounting.
Automating reconciliations via webhooks reduces manual errors and accelerates monthly accounting closure.
How to effectively manage storage and drop-shipping?
At Stacks, 75% of products are drop-shipped directly by suppliers, while the remaining 25% are stored internally. This combination reduces inventory costs while offering a wide catalog.
Cathy recommends selecting reliable partners, tracking shipping times, and automating tracking notifications. A centralized dashboard helps monitor stock levels and out-of-stocks.
Qstomy offers a fulfillment automation solution that synchronizes Shopify orders with drop-shipping suppliers, generating shipping labels and informing customers in real-time.
Use a real-time dashboard that combines internal stock data with supplier replenishment forecasts for drop-shipping.
Why offering the widest range of payment methods is crucial?
Stacks accepts all cards, Google Checkout, Bill Me Later, PayPal, and other solutions. Cathy highlights that payment diversity reduces cart abandonment, especially for international customers.
It is essential to integrate secure solutions compliant with PCI standards and regularly test the payment process to detect friction points.
The Qstomy tool guides you in choosing Shopify-compatible gateways, optimizes conversion rates, and provides automated reminders in case of payment failures.
Also offer local payment options, such as popular digital wallets in each region, to maximize acceptance.
How does Qstomy help optimize every step of the customer journey?
Qstomy acts as a dedicated AI assistant for Shopify: it recommends the best apps for cart, package tracking, customer service, and upsell strategies. By analyzing your sales data, it proposes concrete actions to increase conversion rates.
For example, it can trigger a cross-sell offer when a customer adds a 'home' category item to their cart, or automatically send a follow-up email after delivery.
Thanks to its native integrations, Qstomy centralizes customer support, returns management, and tracking notifications, thereby reducing response times and improving customer satisfaction.
AI can also suggest post-purchase email campaigns based on previous purchase behaviors, thereby increasing customer lifetime value.
What checklist to follow before launching or scaling your e-commerce store?
In short
Infrastructure : dedicated server or suitable Shopify plan, performance monitoring.
Outils : choose third-party services (search, recommendation, analytics) only after validating ROI.
Team : combine key employees and student freelancers for flexibility and creativity.
Acquisition : prioritize CPA, test PPC campaigns on a small budget before expanding.
SEO : set up product blogs, track performance post-redesign, adjust with a specialized partner.
Logistique : define the drop-shipping/internal stock mix, automate shipping notifications.
Paiement : offer multiple methods, secure transactions, regularly test the checkout flow.
FAQ
Q: Should I invest in an ERP from the launch? : Start with a simple accounting module and migrate when your volume justifies integration.
Q: How to measure the impact of a new provider? : Compare conversion rate and CPA before/after, over a minimum 30-day period.
Q: Can Qstomy manage multichannel customer service? Yes, it centralizes chat, email, and 800 numbers, with automated responses based on your knowledge base.
To go further: What e-commerce strategy for a small brand under $100,000/month? - Qstomy, What is Google Shopping for e-commerce? Definition, feed, and benefits for a store - Qstomy, Integrating CS responses into a useful e-commerce SEO strategy for customers - Qstomy, E-commerce SEO strategy for category pages - Qstomy, How to drive traffic to an online store (SEO, ads, social media) - Qstomy, How to increase e-commerce store sales? - Qstomy, How to optimize an e-commerce site for Google (step-by-step guide) - Qstomy.
Finally, schedule a quarterly review of the checklist to incorporate new market trends and feedback from your team.

Enzo
October 31, 2026


