E-commerce

Which email marketing metrics should be prioritized?

Which email marketing metrics should be prioritized?

October 23, 2026

Are you wondering which email marketing metrics to prioritize for your online store? The open rate remains the benchmark, but it is no longer enough to effectively manage your campaigns. Other data such as click-through rates, deliverability, or conversion are equally critical to understand what works and what needs improvement.

The trap would be to focus on a single metric. Each indicator provides a different perspective: some measure the attractiveness of your products, others the relevance of your offers, and still others the health of your contact list. To optimize your sends, you must cross-reference and compare them with benchmarks tailored to your audience.

So, which email marketing metrics should be prioritized? Here is the agenda:

  • Why is the open rate still the key metric?

  • How to measure engagement with the click-through rate?

  • What importance should be placed on mobile opens?

  • How to detect deliverability issues by domain?

  • What checklist should you adopt to analyze your campaigns?

Let's go.

Summary

Why does the open rate remain the primary indicator?

The open rate remains the benchmark in email marketing. An open is recorded when a recipient receives your message and the 1-pixel tracking image loads within the body of the email. This indicator gives a first indication of the proportion of people who have actually seen your content.

However, this figure must be put in perspective. Not all recipients who open an email automatically download images. Additionally, if the tracking image is placed at the bottom of the message, it may not load. Therefore, the reported open rate is often lower than reality. Despite this limitation, it remains a good indicator of your subscribers' engagement and the effectiveness of your subject line, preheader, and sender name.

Averages vary significantly by sector and the composition of your audience. A 10% rate on a list of 500,000 contacts may be satisfactory, while the same rate for customers who recently purchased would be disappointing. For transactional emails like shipping confirmations, open rates often exceed 75%. The key is to establish benchmarks by segment and message type, then test your subject lines to improve.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

How to measure engagement with the click-through rate?

The click-through rate can be calculated in two ways. The first involves dividing the number of clicks by the number of emails delivered. The second, more relevant method, divides the number of clicks by the number of opens. This approach, called click-to-open rate, measures the quality of your content once the message is opened.

This ratio informs you on several points: Is your content engaging? Is your call to action effective? Is your message easy to understand and scan? A low click-to-open rate indicates that the content does not meet recipient expectations or that the message structure lacks clarity.

By analyzing this indicator, you identify areas of your email that need adjustment. For example, a call-to-action button that is too subtle or text that is too long can hinder clicks. Testing different formulations and layouts helps you improve this rate and, by extension, the overall effectiveness of your campaigns.

What importance should be placed on mobile opens?

Open behaviors differ depending on the device used. Desktop users often open emails during working hours, while mobile users are more active in the evenings and on weekends. For each device, it is useful to establish benchmarks and test different send times.

If your subscribers interact and convert well from their smartphones, it is wise to optimize your send times to capture more of this audience. For some brands, mobile devices account for up to 75% of all opens. Ignoring this trend would mean neglecting a major part of your readership.

Adapting your emails to mobile format is therefore essential. A responsive design, touch-friendly buttons, and concise text improve the reading experience on small screens. By monitoring open and click rates by device, you adjust your strategy to better meet your subscribers' habits.

How to improve mobile clicks?

Click-through rates on mobile are generally lower than on desktop. Two main factors explain this difference: the difficulty of clicking precisely on a touch screen and the recipient's level of interest in the offer. Maximizing mobile clicks must be a priority for most brands.

To improve this rate, ensure your call-to-action buttons are large enough and well-spaced. A link that is too small or too close to another element can cause accidental clicks or frustrate the user. Also simplify your message so the essentials are visible without excessive scrolling.

Test different layouts and font sizes to find what works best on mobile. The goal is to reduce friction between reading and taking action. A smooth journey from the email to the landing page increases your chances of conversion.

How to detect deliverability issues by domain?

Analyzing performance by email domain, such as Gmail, Yahoo, or AOL, helps identify potential deliverability issues. Most email marketing platforms provide a breakdown of the main domains with their respective open and click rates.

If your list's average open rate is 10%, but Gmail addresses only open at 3%, there is likely a specific block or filter from Gmail. This signal alerts you to the need to check your sender reputation or the quality of your content.

By monitoring these metrics, you can act quickly in case of a sudden drop. Cleaning your list, improving email authentication, or adjusting your sending practices are possible actions to restore good deliverability. This domain-based analysis is a valuable diagnostic tool to protect your email channel.

How to interpret the unsubscribe rate?

The unsubscribe rate measures the proportion of recipients who opt out of your list after a campaign. Tracking this metric over time helps understand the causes of departures: sending frequency too high, irrelevant messages, ineffective offers, or disappointing content.

In case of a spike in unsubscribes, analyze what was different in the relevant campaign. A change in tone, an unusual promotion type, or a technical issue could explain a sudden increase. The goal is to keep this rate as low as possible while allowing disinterested subscribers to leave easily.

A high unsubscribe rate is not always negative. It can indicate that your list is being cleaned and that remaining contacts are more engaged. The key is to monitor trends and react quickly when anomalies appear.

How to measure your email conversion rate?

The ultimate goal of e-commerce email marketing is to generate sales. The conversion rate is calculated by dividing the number of conversions, typically purchases, by the number of emails delivered, opened, or clicked. This metric measures the real effectiveness of your campaigns in turning interest into action.

Attributing a conversion to a specific email can be complex. A subscriber might discover a product via your newsletter, read a review on social media, perform a Google search, and then purchase on your site. In this multichannel journey, it is difficult to determine which channel actually generated the sale.

Despite this difficulty, it is important to measure the direct conversion rate, i.e., purchases made immediately after clicking from an email. By testing different content, offers, and calls to action, you progressively improve this rate and maximize the return on investment of your campaigns.

How to analyze the bounce rate?

The bounce rate measures emails that did not reach their recipient. There are two types of bounces: soft bounces, which are temporary, such as a full mailbox, and hard bounces, which are permanent, such as a non-existent address. Each send typically includes a small percentage of bounces, as consumers regularly change their email addresses.

Your email platform should automatically remove hard bounce addresses to protect the deliverability of your entire list. Analyzing bounce rates is particularly important for infrequent sends and new addresses. The first send to a new list may have a higher-than-normal bounce rate, but it should stabilize over time.

A healthy list displays a bounce rate of less than 1%. Beyond that, it is advisable to check the quality of your collection sources and implement regular cleaning processes. A high bounce rate can harm your sender reputation and affect all your future sends.

What secondary indicators should be monitored?

Beyond the main metrics, other indicators provide complementary insights. The social share rate measures the proportion of recipients who share your email on social networks. It indicates whether your content is relevant enough to be shared spontaneously. The forward rate, meanwhile, shows how many people have forwarded your message to a friend.

The list growth rate compares the number of new subscribers to unsubscribes. A positive growth indicates that your acquisition strategy is working. Finally, the deliverability rate measures the proportion of emails that actually reach the inbox, without being classified as spam. A low rate signals reputation or content issues.

These secondary indicators help you refine your understanding of engagement and the health of your email channel. By combining them with the main metrics, you get a complete view of your performance and can prioritize your optimization actions.

How to create benchmarks tailored to your audience?

To correctly interpret your indicators, it is essential to create benchmarks tailored to your audience and your message types. A 20% open rate on a list of recent customers is excellent, while the same rate on a list of cold prospects may be insufficient. Segment your data by purchase behavior, tenure, or registration source.

Also compare your performance by email type: newsletters, transactional emails, promotional campaigns, or re-engagement emails. Each of these formats has different expectations regarding opens and clicks. A order confirmation email will naturally have a much higher open rate than a weekly newsletter.

Once your benchmarks are established, regularly test your subject lines, preheaders, and sender names to improve your rates. Analyze results by segment and adjust your strategy accordingly. This iterative approach allows you to continuously optimize your campaigns and increase their effectiveness.

How does Qstomy improve your email marketing metrics?

Qstomy, the Shopify AI agent, can complement your email marketing strategy by enhancing the post-purchase experience. By guiding your customers toward purchase through personalized recommendations, upsell suggestions, and package tracking, it increases the value of each contact. A satisfied customer is more likely to open your next emails and click on your offers.

The agent also intervenes in abandoned cart recovery and after-sales service. By quickly resolving your customers' questions, it reduces friction that can lead to unsubscribes. A smooth customer relationship builds trust and improves your engagement metrics in the long term.

Finally, Qstomy leverages data from your Shopify store to personalize interactions. This data-driven approach helps you better understand your customers and adapt your messages. To go further, discover how training an e-commerce chatbot with Shopify data or how to use CRM data to improve your customer support.

What checklist should you adopt to analyze your campaigns?

To effectively analyze your email campaigns, follow this checklist:

  • Taux d’ouverture : compare by segment and email type to evaluate the appeal of your subject lines.

  • Email click-through rate : measure the relevance of your content and the effectiveness of your calls to action.

  • Performances mobiles : check open and click rates on smartphones to optimize your sends.

  • Deliverability by domain : identify potential blocks and protect your sender reputation.

  • Unsubscribe and bounce rates : monitor anomalies and regularly clean your list.

In short

Open rate remains the benchmark metric, but it must be complemented by click-through rates, mobile performance, and deliverability. Establish benchmarks by segment and test continuously to improve your results.

FAQ

What is the average open rate for an e-commerce email? It varies significantly by sector and list composition. Transactional emails often exceed 75%, while promotional newsletters typically range between 10% and 30%.

How can I improve my click-through rate? Test different calls to action, simplify your layout, and ensure your content matches subscriber expectations.

What to do in case of a high bounce rate? Clean your list, verify your collection sources, and ensure your email platform automatically removes hard bounce addresses.

To go further: Why use social media for e-commerce customer service? - Qstomy, Integrating CS responses into a useful e-commerce SEO strategy for customers - Qstomy, How to drive traffic to an online store (SEO, ads, social media) - Qstomy, How to optimize an e-commerce site for Google (step-by-step guide) - Qstomy, Social sales channels: reach more customers on Shopify - Qstomy.

Enzo

October 23, 2026

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.