E-commerce

Which return frauds to watch out for during the holidays?

Which return frauds to watch out for during the holidays?

October 28, 2026

Wondering which return frauds could derail your year-end results? Three patterns recur every holiday season: wearing an item then returning it, returns stemming from purchases made with stolen cards, and cross-retail returns without receipts from one merchant to another. These practices increase your costs, payment disputes, and stock losses. They also erode your team's trust, leading them to doubt every legitimate request.

The trap is believing that return fraud only affects large chains. Online, every order shipped without delivery confirmation becomes an open door. A return granted too quickly costs far more than a disappointed customer. Conversely, an overly rigid policy drives away honest buyers, who represent the vast majority of your revenue.

Good news: most of these patterns leave traces detectable even before the refund is issued. You just need to know where to look and what to document.

So, which return frauds to watch out for during the holidays? Here's what we'll cover:

  • Why does the holiday season amplify the risk of return fraud?

  • How exactly does wardrobing work on an online store?

  • How to distinguish a fraudster from a customer hesitating between two sizes?

  • Why do purchases made with stolen cards often end up as counter returns?

  • What checklist should you implement before the holidays?

Let's go.

Summary

Why does the holiday season amplify the risk of return fraud?

The holidays create a perfect storm: high volumes, seasonal staff, tight deadlines, and impatient customers. Teams process returns in bulk and verify less. Fraudsters know this and time their operations to this window. A picker sorting three times more packages than usual won't have time to open a box to check the item's actual condition.

According to a survey by the National Retail Federation involving 103 retailers, return fraud already cost physical retailers $3.48 billion in a single season. E-commerce faces similar pressure, with a nuance: without physical contact, it's harder to verify the actual condition of a returned item, and distance facilitates anonymity.

Each fraudulent return hits twice: you lose the product's value and incur a payment dispute. On a small shop, just a few cases can wipe out a month's margin. Not to mention the time spent processing cases, responding to banks, and restocking unsellable items.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

How exactly does wardrobing work on an online store?

Wardrobing is buying an item with the intention of using it, then returning it for a full refund. The classic scenario: a person orders an expensive ski jacket, spends a week on the slopes, then sends the jacket back claiming a refund and free return shipping.

The same pattern applies to party accessories, high-end bedding, centerpieces, or even a TV delivered just before a reception. The merchant ships carefully, and once the event is over, the item returns. Some take it further by ordering multiple sizes of the same garment to keep only the one that fits at the time of the event.

The stakes are twofold: the product loses its resale value, and your return logistics run for nothing. Without proof of use, refusing a refund is nearly impossible. An item worn for a night often remains presentable, making detection difficult without meticulous inspection.

How to distinguish a fraudster from a customer hesitating between two sizes?

The line isn't always clear. A customer who orders an item in two sizes, keeps the one that fits, and returns the other is not a fraudster. In fact, some retailers encourage this practice to reassure buyers before purchase.

Wardrobing is identified by intent: consuming the item's use then demanding full value. The weak signal is a return just after a dated event, or an item returned with signs of use. A hesitant customer returns quickly; a fraudster waits until after the holidays are over.

To cut through the noise, bet on transparency. Clearly state in your policy what is accepted and what is not, and reiterate condition requirements. Some people don't even realize they are committing fraud. A clear page on return fees helps set expectations before purchase. The goal is not to lecture, but to make the rule obvious to everyone.

Why do purchases made with stolen cards often end up as counter returns?

This scheme primarily affects multichannel merchants present both online and in-store. The fraudster uses stolen card data to place an order online, waits for delivery, then returns the item at a physical store to get cash. The process seems harmless, and that is precisely what makes it effective.

A case observed in the US: thieves obtained card numbers from a parts supplier in California. They bought goods or gift cards online, then converted everything to cash at the counter. The physical return served as the final money laundering step.

The merchant loses twice: the money paid to the fraudster, and then a payment dispute opened by the actual cardholder. Prevention relies on vigilance on orders before payment and a dedicated detection tool. Also ensure your in-store teams do not process refunds without ID.

What is cross-return without a receipt and why does it cause concern?

This is the most discreet fraud. According to the NRF survey cited above, about 35 percent of retailers did not require any ID for a return. This laxity opens the door to cross-return without a receipt.

The scenario: the fraudster buys a high-value item online with standard shipping. The carrier often leaves the package at the door without delivery confirmation. The fraudster claims they never received the item and files a dispute with their bank.

Meanwhile, they return the same item at a more lenient physical store. Even if the store only offers store credit, that credit can be resold online and converted to cash. This is why a suivi de livraison fiable.

How does a return policy truly limit abuse?

Your policy is your first filter. Three levers work well for online stores: explicitly forbid wearing an item before return, shorten the return window, and refuse orders from customers who return compulsively.

Shortening the window reduces the fraudster's maneuvering room, as they often rely on generous deadlines. But beware: a window that is too tight also penalizes honest customers. The balance lies around your actual delivery times.

Refusing a customer is never pleasant. Yet, an excessive return history is an objective signal. Document your rules and apply them consistently to avoid any sense of arbitrariness.

Why does delivery confirmation change the game?

Without proof of delivery, you cannot contest a payment dispute. A carrier that leaves a package at a door without a signature leaves you defenseless when the customer claims they received nothing.

For high-value orders, require signature confirmation, a pickup point, or in-store pickup. These options significantly reduce cross-return without a receipt, which relies precisely on the lack of proof.

For standard packages, keep a usable record: tracking number, timestamp, delivery photo. These elements weigh heavily during a dispute and deter less determined fraudsters. The cost of these options remains far lower than the amount of a lost dispute.

What signals should alert your team during the holidays?

Certain patterns frequently appear among end-of-year fraudsters. Watch for them without falling into paranoia.

  • Grouped returns : multiple high-value items returned just after an event date.

  • Historique de litiges : a customer who has already opened a payment dispute on a previous order.

  • Inconsistent address and payment : shipping and billing addresses far apart, or multiple payment attempts.

  • Worn items : signs of use, odors, opened packaging, or removed tags.

Cross-reference these signals with your usual volume: a normal customer might trigger one flag, rarely three at once.

How to analyze return patterns to reduce fraud at the source?

A significant portion of fraudulent returns resembles ordinary returns. By categorizing each reason, you can distinguish genuine product issues from abuse.

For example, repeated returns on the same model due to size signal a product listing issue, not fraud. Conversely, returns without a specific reason, submitted late and in groups, warrant closer examination.

This analysis also helps improve the shopping experience. By understanding why your customers return a product, you reduce the overall return volume and drown out fraud in less noise. It's a virtuous cycle: fewer returns to process, more time to verify suspicious cases.

How to communicate your return rules without alienating your customers?

A poorly explained anti-fraud policy comes across as distrust. Tone matters as much as content. Remind customers of the framework at the right moment without turning every buyer into a suspect.

Display key conditions at checkout: required condition, deadline, potential fees. A well-presented free shipping threshold, for example on a dedicated page for free shipping thresholdsshows you are playing fair.

For sensitive questions, such as returns after an online purchase, a clear answer on who pays return shipping fees avoids misunderstandings. A readable and honest policy retains good customers and discourages fraudsters without looking like a prison regulation.

How does Qstomy help filter suspicious returns after the holidays?

Qstomy is an AI agent for Shopify stores: it guides buyers to the right product, pushes recommendations and cross-sells, manages the cart, tracks packages, and handles customer service. Over 100 merchants already use it daily.

Its value against fraud lies in traceability. Package tracking keeps a record of delivery, and customer support centralizes exchanges with the client. You keep the history of returns and claims in one place.

The agent also handles lingering questions: remote purchases, in-store trials before validation, or a request for returns after trying on. Clear responses, clean histories, prioritizing customer relationships over systematic suspicion.

What checklist should you implement before the holidays?

Here is the checklist to review before the year-end peak.

  • Politique claire : prohibit wearing an item and then returning it, set a realistic window.

  • Preuve de remise : require signature or pickup point for high-value orders.

  • Detection : fraud prevention tool and monitoring of suspicious orders.

  • Dispute tracking : refuse customers with a proven history of disputes, maintain an internal list.

  • Customer responses : anticipate objections avant achat and delivery questions.

In short

Wardrobing, returns of stolen cards, cross-returns without receipts: three frauds that inflate your costs and disputes. Clear rules, proof of delivery, and good customer tracking are enough to deter some of them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should you remove free return shipping? Not necessarily. It is better to set conditions than to remove it entirely.

Can you refuse a return without telling the customer? No. Apply your rules consistently and explain them.

Is a return history enough to refuse a customer? A single signal is not enough, but a body of evidence is, with written rules.

Enzo

October 28, 2026

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.