E-commerce

Why do retailers criticize the interchange fee regulation?

Why do retailers criticize the interchange fee regulation?

November 1, 2026

You wonder why retailers find the interchange fee regulation disappointing?

In short, merchants believe the text preserves the Visa-MasterCard duopoly, limits innovation, and does not truly benefit small shops.

The issue is complex: fees remain opaque, financial compensation is minimal, and the rules could hinder new payment solutions.

Furthermore, industry players highlight that limited cost visibility prevents merchants from comparing offers, reinforcing the dominant position of traditional networks. Additionally, the lack of a true competitive framework hinders the emergence of more agile platforms capable of reducing margins and offering a better customer experience.

So why do retailers criticize this regulation? On the agenda:

  • What are interchange fees and how are they imposed on merchants?

  • Does the regulation allow merchants to pass fees on to their customers?

  • Does the regulation threaten the emergence of alternative payment solutions?

  • How can Qstomy help merchants master these fees?

  • What checklist to follow before choosing a payment solution?

Let's go.

Furthermore, the analysis reveals that enhanced transparency would allow small businesses to better plan their budgets and invest more effectively in growth.

Summary

What are interchange fees and how are they imposed on merchants?

Interchange fees are commissions charged by card networks every time a customer pays with a credit or debit card. They are set by Visa and MasterCard and applied uniformly to all merchants, with no possibility for individual negotiation.

These fees generally represent 1.5% to 2% of the amount of each transaction, which translates to tens of thousands of euros annually for an average merchant.

This pricing structure, which does not account for volume or industry sector, heavily penalizes small shops that lack the critical mass needed to absorb these costs. Furthermore, merchants often have to accept these fees as immutable data, unable to engage in direct negotiations with the networks, which reinforces the sense of injustice and unequal treatment.

In addition, the use of flow analysis tools allows merchants to identify times when fees are highest and adjust their payment strategies accordingly.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Why are interchange fees considered invisible to many merchants?

For many e-commerce merchants, interchange fees are integrated into the overall transaction cost and appear as an 'invisible' charge. Bank statements do not always detail the exact portion dedicated to interchange, making visibility and comparison difficult.

This opacity prevents merchants from challenging rates or seeking less costly alternatives, thereby consolidating the dominant position of the two major networks.

In practice, this lack of granularity means shops cannot identify the heaviest expense categories, nor measure the impact of potential optimization. They end up absorbing invisible costs that erode their margins while being limited in their pricing strategies.

A customized dashboard can, however, make these costs more readable and help in making decisions based on concrete data.

How does the current regulation maintain the Visa-MasterCard duopoly?

The text of the regulation, negotiated directly between Visa, MasterCard, and lawyers representing merchants, does not challenge the dominance of these two players. No competitive mechanism is introduced, and the two networks remain free to set their own rates.

Moreover, the regulation immunizes the giants against future lawsuits, blocking any legislative evolution that could favor the emergence of alternatives.

As a result, small and medium-sized businesses find themselves trapped in a framework where pricing conditions are dictated without challenge. The lack of transparency obligations or fee caps further accentuates the competitive disadvantage compared to large players who can negotiate better rates thanks to their volume.

Studies show that a clause for periodic rate review could mitigate this locking effect and encourage more innovation.

What financial impacts would the regulation have on small and medium businesses?

The planned payment of $7.2 billion translates, according to NRF estimates, into approximately $6 billion in damages and $1.2 billion in interchange fee rebates. This sum is distributed among nearly 8 million US businesses, meaning most small and medium businesses will receive only a few cents.

In practice, most real savings are absorbed by large retailers who hold the majority of sales volume, leaving smaller ones in an unchanged situation.

Furthermore, the flat-rate distribution does not account for the variability of actual costs borne by each business. Thus, a small store already paying a high interchange rate will see no notable improvement, while giants, already well-positioned, can reinvest these funds to strengthen their competitive advantages.

A targeted approach, where small businesses receive rebates proportional to their volume, would improve the fairness of the mechanism.

Does the regulation allow merchants to pass fees on to their customers?

Yes, the text allows merchants to add a surcharge to card payments to compensate for interchange fees. However, this practice remains controversial and can lead to a loss of consumer trust.

On a Shopify site, applying a surcharge without transparency can also violate the policies of certain payment processors, further complicating cart management.

Furthermore, legislation in several jurisdictions imposes strict limits on the maximum surcharge amount and requires it to be clearly displayed before order completion. Ignoring these requirements exposes merchants to administrative penalties and reputational damage.

In practice, clear communication and pre-determined cost calculations avoid unpleasant surprises and strengthen customer trust.

Does the regulation threaten the emergence of alternative payment solutions?

The regulation expands the definition of 'card networks' to include new mobile and online services. By grouping them under the same legal shield, traditional networks can hinder the development of innovative applications like cryptocurrency wallets or instant payment solutions.

Retailers seeking to test alternatives then find their options limited, reinforcing dependence on the two giants.

This situation discourages startups proposing payment models based on blockchain or crypto-assets, as they must now comply with tariff and transparency requirements similar to those of historical players, increasing their market entry costs.

A distinct regulatory clarification for decentralized services could revitalize the ecosystem and offer more choices to merchants.

What are the risks associated with rules imposed by card networks, such as PCI DSS?

The PCI DSS standard places the responsibility on merchants to secure card data, even though technical responsibility actually lies with the networks. This constraint forces e-commerce businesses to invest in costly compliance solutions.

If card networks do not enhance the security of their own cards, merchants remain exposed to penalties and reputational losses in the event of a breach.

In practice, PCI DSS compliance requires regular audits, infrastructure updates, and sometimes the use of tokenization services. For small businesses, these expenses represent a significant portion of the operational budget, limiting their margins and capacity to invest in other growth projects.

Shared SaaS solutions can, however, reduce the cost of obtaining certification for smaller players.

How do retailer associations attempt to influence the legislator?

The National Retail Federation (NRF), the Retail Industry Leaders Association (RILA), and other groups have sent an open letter to members of Congress, characterizing the regulation as 'maintaining a duopoly'. They call for stricter scrutiny and increased legislative involvement.

These organizations also use public campaigns and meetings with senators to highlight negative effects on consumer prices and competitiveness.

Furthermore, they commission detailed economic impact studies demonstrating that payment market concentration increases costs for end consumers and limits innovation. These reports are often presented at trade committees to push for legislative reform including transparency obligations and interchange fee caps.

Coordinated lobbying with fintech startups could accelerate the adoption of more protective measures for small businesses.

What alternatives exist to reduce interchange fees without waiting for new regulations?

Merchants can negotiate directly with alternative processors, integrate fixed-fee payment solutions, or encourage the use of low-fee debit cards. Some platforms offer subscription models where fees are capped.

On Shopify, it is possible to activate gateways like Stripe or PayPal that offer different rates based on volume, or to offer bank transfer payments when relevant.

Additionally, stores can implement loyalty programs that incentivize customers to choose less expensive payment methods, such as integrated digital wallets or SEPA payments. This proactive approach allows for a reduction in the proportion of transactions subject to high interchange fees while improving the customer experience.

Adopting predictive analytics helps anticipate price fluctuations and adjust payment strategies in real time.

How can Qstomy help merchants manage payment fees and optimize the cart?

Qstomy integrates a purchase process optimization engine that automatically suggests the least expensive payment method for each customer while maintaining a seamless experience.

Thanks to real-time analytics, Qstomy indicates which transaction fees apply, proposes alternatives like digital wallet payments, and adjusts the cart to avoid unnecessary surcharges. Learn more.

The tool also automates billing data retrieval, verifies PCI DSS compliance, and generates detailed reports for each payment channel, facilitating strategic decision-making and continuous optimization of transaction costs.

Additionally, Qstomy offers scenario simulations that allow visualizing the financial impact of each payment method before deployment.

How does Qstomy help master interchange fees and improve conversion?

By analyzing each transaction, Qstomy identifies applied interchange fees and provides personalized recommendations to reduce the average cost per order. This results in higher margins and a larger average order value.

Furthermore, Qstomy automates transparent communication of potential surcharges, strengthens customer trust, and reduces cart abandonment. Discover our best practices.

The platform also offers A/B testing scenarios to evaluate the impact of different payment methods on conversion rates. By combining these tests with alerts on fee fluctuations, merchants can quickly adjust their strategies and maximize net revenue.

A proactive alert function immediately notifies teams when a price change occurs at a partner processor.

What checklist to follow before choosing a payment solution and what are the common FAQs?

Checklist before choosing

  • Total cost : frais d’interchange, frais fixes, frais d’abonnement.

  • Compatibility : native integration with Shopify, support for local cards.

  • Transparence : visibility of fees on each transaction.

  • Security : PCI DSS compliance, data protection.

  • Support : assistance disponible, documentation claire.

FAQ rapides

  • "Can I apply a surcharge?": yes, but it must be clearly displayed.

  • "What is the best way to reduce fees?": group sales by volume and negotiate with multiple processors.

  • "Do fees vary by country?": yes, interchange rates differ by network and region.

To delve deeper into each point, consult our guides: e-commerce SEO strategy, Sales tax in Texas, Gift and professional invoices.

To go further: How to handle customer questions about taxes applied to gift cards - Qstomy, Which platform to choose for selling digital products? - Qstomy. Additionally, explore our articles on the legal compliance of surcharges and best practices for optimizing payment costs in various European countries.

Integrating a pilot test phase before definitively choosing your solution allows you to validate real savings and adjust your operational settings.

Enzo

November 1, 2026

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.