E-commerce

Which email marketing practices must you absolutely avoid?

Which email marketing practices must you absolutely avoid?

October 30, 2026

Are you wondering which email marketing practices to avoid?

Avoiding certain 'best practices' unsuited to your Shopify store allows you to save time, improve deliverability, and increase conversions.

Every store has its specifics; what works for a large group does not necessarily apply to a niche merchant.

So which email marketing practices should you really ignore? On the agenda:

  • Why not remove images from the main message?

  • Are open rates really the most important KPI?

  • Is it wise to remove inactive subscribers?

  • How to test and measure the real impact of a new technique?

  • What alternatives exist to re-engage less active contacts?

Let's go.

We will also explore how to measure the real impact of each variant, avoid pitfalls that waste your budget, and set up continuous improvement processes for your campaigns.

Finally, you will discover concrete tips to turn every data point into a profitable action.

Summary

Why not ban images from the main message?

Many recommend placing text and the CTA in HTML only, leaving images outside the main message. This approach can save design time, but it neglects the power of well-thought-out images. On Shopify, Qstomy templates offer optimized image blocks that display even when the customer disables images, thanks to rich alt text. For a store shipping creative products, a 'product highlight' image captures attention much faster than a line of text. If your team has the graphic resources, prioritize clear visuals and use alt text to ensure readability.

Additionally, test different formats (WEBP, JPEG‑2000) and ensure each image has a descriptive alt attribute; this strengthens your email SEO and improves the experience for readers who cannot see the images.

A well-placed image can even increase the click-through rate by 15% when accompanied by a targeted CTA.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Are open rates really the supreme criterion?

Open rates are often the first KPI observed, but they tell only part of the story. A high open rate may simply reflect a catchy subject line without leading to clicks or sales. On Shopify, Qstomy combines open rate analysis with click-through rates, revenue per email, and conversion rates. By tracking these metrics, you see if your campaign truly influences the cart. Furthermore, segment your lists: recent customers open more than prospects who have never purchased. Thus, open rates must be contextualized with other metrics to guide your decisions.

Also consider measuring average time spent on the email and the full-read rate; these data points offer additional insight into your audience's real engagement.

By combining these measures, you can identify topics that truly convert interest into purchases.

Purge 'inactive' subscribers: what are the risks?

Massively removing contacts who haven't opened your emails seems logical for improving deliverability. Yet, this practice often eliminates prospects who could be reactivated with a different approach. ISPs evaluate sending frequency to inactive lists; a brutal cleanup may improve the score in the short term, but you lose the opportunity to engage these users with a less frequent flow or targeted incentives. Instead of deleting them, create a 're-engagement' segment and send a monthly reminder message. This strategy preserves your domain reputation while offering subscribers a second chance.

A well-designed win-back campaign, with a dynamic offer tailored to the customer's past behavior, increases the chances of re-conversion without harming your deliverability.

Also test a brief questionnaire to understand the reasons for disengagement.

How to effectively test email campaigns?

A/B testing remains the essential tool for validating every hypothesis. On your Shopify store, compare two variants of subject line, visual, or CTA on a small percentage of your list, then deploy the winning version. Use Qstomy reports to measure click-through rates, revenue generated, and conversion rates, not just open rates. Repeat tests regularly: preferences evolve with seasons and new product launches. A structured testing cycle prevents you from deploying 'best practices' that do not work for your audience.

Additionally, explore multivariate tests that allow you to evaluate multiple elements simultaneously (button color, text position) to optimize each send more finely.

Document every result to build an internal knowledge base.

What place should transactional emails have in your strategy?

Transactional emails (order confirmations, shipment tracking, review requests) boast an open rate exceeding 80%. They offer a unique opportunity to build trust and encourage a new purchase. Integrate product recommendations or exclusive offers into these messages, leveraging Qstomy's recommendation engine which provides upsells tailored to the customer's cart. Thus, every step of the purchase journey becomes an opportunity for additional sales without increasing your workload.

By personalizing these recommendations based on purchase history and browsing preferences, you boost average revenue per email while delivering an ultra-relevant experience.

Feel free to add a limited-time promo code to maximize impact.

How to segment intelligently to avoid generalizations?

Fine-grained segmentation solves the problem of misleading metrics. Create groups based on purchase behavior: new customers, loyal customers, abandoned carts, inactive for 6 months, etc. Qstomy automatically syncs these segments with your Shopify store, allowing you to send ultra-personalized messages. For example, a customer who bought school supplies last year might receive a promotion on new back-to-school kits. By segmenting, every campaign becomes relevant, increasing click-through rates and revenue per email.

Integrate the RFM method (Recency, Frequency, Monetary) to create even more precise segments capable of revealing loyalty opportunities often invisible in broader categories.

Combine RFM with purchase propensity scores to refine further.

What additional metrics to track beyond open rates?

Beyond opens, monitor click-through rate (CTR), revenue per email (RPE), conversion rate (CVR), and unsubscribe rate. A high CTR but low CVR indicates an issue on the landing page, while a rising unsubscribe rate signals audience fatigue. Qstomy provides a unified dashboard where these KPIs are cross-referenced with Shopify sales data, offering a clear overview. By tracking these indicators, you quickly identify what works and what needs adjustment.

Don't forget to analyze the spam complaint rate and inbox placement; these metrics directly influence your domain reputation and future deliverability.

Daily monitoring helps you react before issues escalate.

How to re-engage low-active subscribers without deleting them?

Re-engagement involves gentle and incentivized campaigns. Offer a welcome coupon valid for 48 hours, or send exclusive content (video tutorial, creation guide) to remind them of your store's value. Limit frequency to one monthly send for this segment to avoid overwhelming them. Use Qstomy's cart recovery module to remind customers of items left pending, even after several weeks. This approach transforms 'dormant' subscribers into active customers without sacrificing your domain reputation.

You can enhance this effect by introducing a points or badges system: returning contacts earn rewards, stimulating engagement in a gamified way.

Analyze responses to adjust future offers.

Why does deliverability take precedence over send volume?

Sending more does not guarantee better results if messages do not reach the inbox. ISPs (Google, Apple, Outlook) evaluate your domain reputation based on complaint rates, unsubscribes, and engagement. Qstomy integrates an email validation tool and reputation tracking, helping you maintain good deliverability. Regularly clean invalid addresses, avoid mass sends to inactive segments, and prioritize content relevance. Good deliverability ensures that every campaign effort is actually seen by your customers.

Also ensure your SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records are correctly configured; they strengthen trust with email providers and reduce the risk of spam placement.

Regularly test your sends across different providers to detect blocks.

How to leverage AI to personalize emails?

Qstomy's AI analyzes purchase behaviors, browsing history, and each customer's preferences to generate real-time product recommendations. Integrate these suggestions directly into your email campaigns: 'You might like these items' or 'Complete your creative kit with'. AI also adjusts the optimal send time based on each segment's open habits. Thus, every email becomes ultra-personalized, increasing click-through rates and average order value.

Additionally, let AI propose specific subject lines for each segment; tests show that automatically generated subjects improve open rates by an average of 12%.

You can refine the algorithms by integrating post-purchase feedback.

How does Qstomy help optimize your email campaigns?

Qstomy acts as a dedicated AI assistant for Shopify stores. It syncs your subscriber lists, creates dynamic segments, and offers ready-to-use email templates, including optimized image blocks and smart CTAs. Its dashboard combines email metrics with Shopify sales, allowing you to instantly see which email generated which revenue. Furthermore, Qstomy manages deliverability, validates addresses, and recommends the best send time through machine learning. By centralizing these functions, you save time and improve every campaign without relying on multiple tools.

The optimal send time prediction feature uses historical open data to select the most receptive time slot, thereby increasing conversion chances from the very first moment.

A clear interface facilitates onboarding even for beginners.

What checklist before sending your next campaign?

In short

  • Recipient list : verify segments, remove invalid addresses.

  • Subject and pre-header : testez deux variantes via A/B.

  • Contenu visuel : ensure important images have alt text.

  • CTA clair : use a single call to action per email.

  • Timing : choose the optimal send time based on history.

FAQ

  • Should I always test the subject line? Yes; the subject line influences the open rate, even if it's only part of the puzzle.

  • What is the best KPI to track? Combine click-through rate, revenue per email, and conversion rate for a complete view.

  • How to reactivate a dormant subscriber? Send them a personalized offer, reduce frequency, and use Qstomy's re-engagement module.

By following this checklist, you maximize your chances of success and avoid common pitfalls.

To go further: SEO for e-commerce sites: strategies that really work - Qstomy, Training an e-commerce chatbot with Shopify: using the right data without creating bad responses - Qstomy, Why use social media for e-commerce customer service? - Qstomy, AI Chatbot and GDPR: Best Practices for an E-commerce Store - Qstomy, How to improve conversion rates for e-commerce sales? - Qstomy, E-commerce CRM and customer support: using the right data to respond better - Qstomy, E-commerce SEO strategy for category pages - Qstomy.

Finally, always test your email on major mobile clients (iOS, Android) before sending to ensure smooth reading and avoid rendering issues that can harm your performance.

Remember to collect user feedback to iterate quickly.

Enzo

October 30, 2026

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.