E-commerce

How to generate traffic using Facebook Similar Audiences?

How to generate traffic using Facebook Similar Audiences?

October 29, 2026

Wondering how to generate traffic using Facebook Similar Audiences? In short, simply create an audience from your existing customers and then extend the reach to profiles that resemble them, to reach thousands of prospects ready to discover your store.

This technique relies on Facebook's powerful targeting engine, but requires properly configuring your pixels and lists to avoid audience sizes that are too small or low match rates. Rigorous performance tracking from the first days allows for quick parameter adjustments.

Finally, data quality plays a decisive role: the richer and better segmented your sources are, the more relevant the Similar Audiences will be. We detail each step below to maximize your results.

By applying these best practices, you will see not only an increase in traffic but also an improvement in conversion rate, ROAS, and customer loyalty, thanks to hyper-relevant targeting that continuously adapts to purchasing behaviors.

Summary

How to create a dynamic audience from website traffic?

Launch the creation from the Facebook Ads Manager by opening the menu Outils → Audiences puis Create audience → Custom audience. Choisissez Website traffic to display the pixel code. If you already have a pixel, copy-paste the code into the developer section or, more simply, use Google Tag Manager. In GTM, create a 'Facebook Pixel' tag, select the 'All Pages' trigger, and publish.

Once the pixel is active, return to the Audience Manager, name your audience 'All site visitors', and validate. Facebook will automatically populate the list as soon as 20 visitors with Facebook data are recorded. You can then track the evolution of your dynamic audience in real time.

Qstomy Tip: our AI detects the right moment to activate the pixel and sends you an alert when an audience reaches the minimum threshold, thus avoiding the 'Audience too small' message. Remember to test different events (page view, add to cart) to refine data collection and obtain more precise signals.

Additionally, configure the Facebook Conversions API to synchronize server-side events, which improves tracking reliability and opens the door to optimization strategies based on first-party data.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

How to build a static audience from an email list?

In the same menu Audiences, choisissez Custom audience → Customer list. You can copy-paste your email addresses directly or import a CSV file. Ensure the addresses are associated with Facebook profiles; generally, 60% to 80% of emails will be recognized.

Give your audience an explicit name, such as 'Customers who purchased in 2023', then click Suivant. Facebook will immediately offer to create a similar audience based on this source. This step creates the foundation that will be expanded.

To maximize the match rate, combine your email list with your newsletter audience and comply with GDPR requirements by verifying explicit consent. Fine segmentation (VIP customers, new buyers) will allow you to launch several more targeted similar audiences.

It is also advisable to create exclusions (recent customers, prospects already targeted) to avoid redundant retargeting and optimize the reach of new audiences.

How to set up a similar audience and choose its optimal size?

After selecting your source audience, click Create similar audience. You must specify the target country and the audience size. The slider ranges from 1% (approximately 1.9M users) to 10% (approximately 19.2M) of the country's population.

The larger the size, the broader the audience becomes but the less similar it is to your source. In practice, start with 1% to test relevance, then gradually expand if performance is good.

If your source has fewer than 100 contacts, Facebook will display 'Source too small'. In this case, combine multiple lists (customers, newsletter subscribers, site visitors) to reach the recommended threshold. Regularly monitor the match rate and adjust the size based on cost per acquisition.

Also ensure you monitor frequency of exposure and set caps to avoid ad fatigue, especially when working with broad audiences.

How to optimize ad creatives to convert these new prospects?

Once your similar audience is ready, create ad sets with engaging visuals and a clear message. Highlight your value proposition, add a strong call to action ('Discover our best sellers', 'Enjoy 10% off').

Use dynamic product formats if you have a Shopify catalog; Facebook will automatically display the most relevant items. Do not forget to include link extensions to guide prospects to product pages, FAQs, or live chat.

Test multiple text and image variants (A/B testing) to identify the headlines that convert best. Qstomy syncs your product pages with conversion tracking and provides headline recommendations based on past performance.

Focus on short titles, clear benefits, and social proof (reviews, ratings). Short videos or product carousels can increase engagement time and CTR.

How to measure the performance of your similar audiences?

Track key metrics in the Ads Manager: impressions, clicks, CPC, conversion rate, and cost per acquisition. Complement the analysis with Google Analytics (GA4) to measure qualified traffic, bounce rate, and average order value.

In Google Analytics, create a 'Similar Audience' segment to compare the behavior of visitors from this source with that of organic visitors.

Qstomy generates weekly reports that aggregate these metrics and suggest optimizations (budget adjustment, targeting changes). Also integrate heatmaps or session recordings to understand the post-click journey.

Consider adjusting the attribution window (7, 28, or 90 days) based on your purchase cycle and create custom conversions to track high-value actions like newsletter sign-ups or adding items to the cart.

What budget should be allocated to a similar audience campaign?

Start modestly: a daily budget of €5 to €10 allows you to collect sufficient data without excessive risk. Analyze CPL (cost per lead) and CPA (cost per acquisition). If performance exceeds your profitability thresholds, increase the budget by 20% every three days.

Test multiple audience sizes (1% vs 5%) with the same budget to identify the balance between reach and relevance. Once your optimal audience is identified, scale up gradually.

Set a target ROAS (e.g., 4:1) and adjust the budget based on results. Daily monitoring prevents wasting spend on underperforming audiences.

Use day-parting to concentrate spending during hours when your audience is most active, and leverage automatic budget optimization campaigns (CBO) to let the algorithm redistribute the budget toward the most profitable ad sets.

How to avoid common pitfalls (audiences too small, low match rates)?

The main obstacle is the source size. Facebook requires at least 100 identifiable contacts. If your base is insufficient, combine multiple lists: customers, newsletter subscribers, blog visitors, etc.

Check the match rate ('Low Match Rate') in the Availability tab. A rate below 30% indicates that most of your emails are not linked to Facebook accounts. Enrich your base by requesting consent optimization during the checkout funnel.

Avoid overlap with retargeting audiences to prevent cannibalizing your performance. Qstomy automatically alerts you when an audience does not meet the threshold and suggests ways to expand your source.

Regularly clean your databases using email verification services to remove invalid addresses and increase the overall match rate.

How to combine similar audiences with retargeting audiences?

A two-step strategy maximizes conversions: first, run your similar audience campaign to attract new visitors, then activate a retargeting campaign for the 30% who clicked but did not purchase.

In the Ads Manager, create two distinct ad sets but share the same overall budget. Use the same creative for consistency, but change the call to action (e.g., 'Add to Cart' for retargeting).

Apply frequency caps to avoid ad fatigue and vary the message between initial discovery and follow-up. This sequencing increases conversion chances without overwhelming the user.

Enhance retargeting with exclusive offers (promo codes, free shipping) to drive immediate conversion, and use intent signals (time spent on page) to prioritize the hottest prospects.

How to leverage similar audiences on Instagram via Ads Manager?

Instagram shares the same advertising platform as Facebook, allowing you to extend your similar audiences to Stories and the News Feed. When creating a campaign, select 'Automatic Placements' or explicitly check 'Instagram'.

Adapt your visuals to the vertical format (1080 × 1920 px) and prioritize short, impactful content. Instagram users respond well to limited offers and promo codes integrated into the visuals.

To ensure brand continuity, Qstomy synchronizes your product catalogs between Facebook and Instagram, avoiding any manual duplication. Remember to enable Instagram Shopping so products are clickable directly from your posts.

Use relevant hashtags and poll or countdown stickers in Stories to encourage interaction and increase organic reach.

How to adapt your similar audiences for Shopping campaigns and dynamic products?

Dynamic Product Ads leverage your Shopify catalog. First, create a similar audience based on your best customers, then associate it with a dynamic ad set that will automatically display relevant products.

In Ads Manager, select 'Product Catalog', choose your Shopify feed, then set the similar audience as the target. Facebook will optimize delivery based on predicted purchase behavior.

Optimize your feed by filling out all properties (title, description, image, price, availability). A complete catalog improves ad relevance and increases the click-through rate.

Group your products by collections (new arrivals, best-sellers, sales) so the system suggests the most suitable items for each similar audience segment.

How does Qstomy help create and manage your similar audiences?

Qstomy, your Shopify AI assistant, simplifies every step. It automatically generates the pixel code, places it via Google Tag Manager, and verifies its functionality in real-time.

Import your customer lists from Shopify or your email service; Qstomy normalizes them, removes duplicates, and calculates the Facebook match rate. Then, the AI suggests the ideal similar audience size based on your conversion history.

The Qstomy dashboard aggregates KPIs (CPC, CPA, ROAS) and sends optimization recommendations weekly. Additionally, it automatically enables conversion tracking, links sales to your campaigns, and helps create personalized upsells and cross-sells from the prospect's first visit. Dedicated support is available to answer your technical questions.

Thanks to machine learning, Qstomy can generate creative variants, predict performance by audience, and automatically recommend the optimal budget for each campaign.

What checklist before launching your first similar audience?

Checklist de lancement

  • Pixel Facebook installed on all pages via GTM.

  • Base client of at least 100 validated contacts (emails, phone numbers).

  • Catalogue produit synchronized with Shopify.

  • Geographic targeting defined (country, region).

  • Budget initial defined (5, 10 €/day).

FAQ rapide

  • What size to choose? Start at 1% then expand.

  • My audience is too small, what to do? Combine lists and increase email volume.

  • How to track sales? Enable conversion tracking in Qstomy and link it to Facebook Ads.

By applying this checklist, you maximize your chances of success from day one. Check each point during the first week of launch, adjust parameters if needed, and measure initial results before scaling.

After launch, schedule a performance audit at 30 days to identify additional optimization opportunities, refine audience segments, and recalibrate budgets based on real data.

To go further: How to drive traffic to an online store (SEO, ads, social media) - Qstomy, How to integrate Shopify with Amazon for products, inventory, and reviews? - Qstomy, Training an e-commerce chatbot with Shopify: using the right data without creating bad responses - Qstomy, Google Analytics for Marketing: Ads, Traffic, and Performance (GA4) - Qstomy, How to reassure buyers before and after purchasing expensive products? - Qstomy, How do e-commerce sites acquire new customers? - Qstomy, How to optimize an e-commerce site for Google (step-by-step guide) - Qstomy.

Enzo

October 29, 2026

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.