E-commerce

What to include in your packages to build loyalty and sell more?

What to include in your packages to build loyalty and sell more?

October 28, 2026

Wondering what you could slip into your packages to bring customers back?

The answer is simple: your package can become a powerful loyalty tool, capable of increasing average order value and repeat orders without additional advertising budget.

Returning customers represent a very small portion of traffic but generate a major share of online sales and often spend significantly more per order. A well-thought-out package thus turns every delivery into a marketing touchpoint at a moment when the customer's attention is at its peak.

Unlike an email that gets lost in a saturated inbox or an ad that is scrolled past without thought, the package arrives directly into the customer's hands during a moment of anticipation and pleasure. It is a rare, intimate channel still largely underutilized by e-commerce merchants. A well-chosen insert can be enough to turn a one-time buyer into a regular customer.

The idea is not to fill every box with useless items, but to design an unboxing experience consistent with your brand. A successful insert creates emotion, guides toward a clear action, and leaves a lasting impression. It is this precise moment that distinguishes a forgotten order from a lasting relationship.

So what to include in your packages to build loyalty and sell more? On the agenda:

  • Why include a discount code in the package?

  • How to offer a free product without breaking your margin?

  • What small pleasure to add to make an impression?

  • How to get more customer reviews after delivery?

  • Why include a catalog or product flyer?

Let's go.

Summary

Why is the package an underutilized marketing lever?

Your package travels to someone's home who has already pulled out their credit card. It's a rare, physical touchpoint, often overlooked.

According to Adobe, customers who return for a second order or more represent only 8% of e-commerce traffic, but generate over 40% of online sales in the United States. And the difference in cart value is striking: a returning customer would spend about three times more than a new one, a loyal customer up to five times more.

The package can also be seen as a targeted direct mail piece. A merchant in the American Northwest compared the cost of their paper mailings, over a dollar per send, with the idea of using the package itself as a marketing medium. The only real question remaining: what to put inside?

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Why include a discount code in the package?

The discount code is the simplest and most measurable idea. Eastbay, a sportswear retailer, slips a large percentage discount into their packages: for example, 15% off any order over $75.

What makes the offer work is its generosity. The customer can use it on anything they want. A too-targeted discount, like 20% off a specific pair, performs poorly because not everyone is interested.

Second advantage: traceability. By tracking the code used, you measure the real effect on sales and adjust the amount, threshold, or duration. Think of a short, readable code and a clear expiration date to create momentum without unnecessary pressure.

Third advantage: cost. A printed coupon costs a few cents, far less than an advertising campaign, and consumes no acquisition budget. You only pay the discount if the customer returns to order, making it one of the most profitable levers in your retention toolkit.

Final tip: slip the coupon into a visible spot, not tucked at the bottom of the box under packing paper. An insert the customer doesn't find at the moment of opening loses all its value.

How to offer a free product without breaking your margin?

Adding a free item creates a surprise effect. Design by Humans, a community t-shirt retailer, included an extra t-shirt with their smile logo in certain orders.

The goal is not to give a second high-value product, but a lightweight item consistent with the brand that serves as a visual reminder and an unexpected gift. The customer feels recognized, and the brand anchors itself in their daily life.

Beware of the internal rule: this gift must remain exceptional. If it becomes systematic and without perceived value, it loses its effect. Choose end-of-line items, homemade goodies, or partner samples, and check your margin before generalizing.

What small pleasure to add to make an impression?

A square of chocolate, a lollipop, or a gift card for a coffee work on the same principle: reward the online purchase to encourage repeat business.

This small pleasure transforms package opening into a pleasant moment, often shared or photographed. This attention is also an opportunity for collaboration: a confectioner can provide samples and a coupon to a clothing retailer, and both brands benefit.

The effect is far from anecdotal. A well-chosen treat triggers a positive emotion and leaves a concrete memory. The customer associates your brand with this moment of pleasure, not just the product received, and talks about it more easily around them than a simply well-packaged item.

Check logistical compatibility: products that don't melt, leak, or resist transport. A sticky gift that damages the order would have the opposite effect of the intended one. Also consider common allergies and clearly indicate the presence of nuts or lactose on the insert.

How to get more customer reviews after delivery?

Reviews are read and influence purchase decisions. A request slipped into the package has two benefits: it brings the customer back to your site, and it produces useful content for future buyers.

Formulate a simple request, without conditions. Keep the ability to modify the text, format, or timing of the follow-up, then track the number of reviews obtained to compare versions.

A point of vigilance: do not offer anything in exchange for a review. This practice is perceived as buying positive reviews and can harm your image. To go further on the role of reviews in the purchase journey, consult our article on customer reviews in the purchase journey.

Why include a catalog or product flyer?

Many merchants focus on highlighting products on the site: related articles, upselling, cross-selling. A catalog or a leaflet included in the package extends this work outside the store.

The customer discovers products they would not have searched for, including those with more comfortable margins. It is also a visual reminder of your brand, useful if the packaging is discreet.

As with other tactics, the effect is easy to measure using a code or a short link. A single leaflet is often sufficient and costs less than a full catalog to print and ship.

How to measure the real impact of these additions?

Each insertion must be tracked. A discount code, a short link, or a question asked at checkout allows you to know if the idea works.

Compare orders with and without the insertion over a given period. Look at the repeat rate, average order value, and the time until the next order. A discount used two months later does not have the same value as a code used in three days.

You can also test one variable at a time: the discount amount, the presence of a gift, the text of the review request. An idea that resonates with your customers is not necessarily the one that performs elsewhere. Record each test in a simple table, with the date, the modified variable, and the result obtained, to avoid repeating the same mistake twice.

For low volumes, do not draw conclusions too quickly: wait for at least a few dozen orders per version before deciding. And remember that a good repeat rate is not enough if the margin of the next order is crushed by the offered discount.

How to avoid the pitfalls of in-package marketing?

The first pitfall is overload. A package filled with flyers, cards, and samples dilutes the message and slows down preparation. One strong insertion is better than five weak ones.

The second pitfall is an offer that is too targeted or conditional. A coupon usable only on a specific product, or with complex restrictions, is often ignored. Keep it broad and readable.

Finally, never monetize reviews. An honest and neutral request preserves your credibility. To address objections that hinder the purchase even before delivery, see our guide on the 30 objections to address on your site.

How to adapt these ideas to expensive or fragile products?

For a high-value cart, the package must first reassure. The customer has invested a lot, and every detail counts: careful protection, clear instructions, and a simple return option.

The discount code remains relevant, but it should value the next step in the journey, for example a complementary accessory or a maintenance service. The gift must be useful, not a gadget.

Also think about human support. A handwritten note, even short, has more impact on this type of order than a generic flyer. It shows that the product was prepared with care and reduces the risk of a disappointing first impression upon opening.

For fragile products, prefer flat, non-abrasive inserts with no risk to the item. Our article on reassuring buyers about expensive products details this logic before and after the purchase.

How to link the package to your customer service?

The package is an opportunity to direct the customer to the right channel. A QR code or a short address to your delivery help page prevents them from searching for a contact at random.

This reduces repetitive questions about delivery times, returns, or shipping fees. These inquiries consume time and sometimes create dissatisfaction right after the purchase.

Carefully craft the label: 'Having an issue with your order?' opens the discussion more easily than 'Customer Service'. A customer who feels guided is more likely to write, and you recover their feedback before it becomes public negative reviews.

Our page on the delivery help page shows how to structure these responses, and our article on displaying free shipping thresholds helps limit questions in advance.

How does Qstomy help turn these ideas into loyalty?

Qstomy is an AI agent for Shopify stores that guides the customer through to purchase and beyond. It handles product recommendations, upselling, cart management, package tracking, and after-sales service.

Concretely, your insertion ideas come to life in the digital journey: a customer who receives a discount code in their package can be re-engaged at the right moment, another looking for their package finds the answer without writing, and an objection about an expensive product is addressed before the order.

Over 100 merchants already use Qstomy to streamline this type of exchange. The agent does not replace your package; it extends the experience you created within it and captures the value of questions asked after delivery.

What checklist should you follow before inserting something into your packages?

In short

The package is a measurable loyalty lever: it reaches customers who already buy, spend more, and return often. Five starting points are enough: a broad discount code, a surprise gift, a small treat, a neutral review request, or a product catalog/flyer.

Checklist avant lancement

  • Is the insert flat, lightweight, and resistant to shipping?

  • Is the offer broad, readable, and trackable?

  • Does the gift respect your margin?

  • Is the review request neutral, without a quid pro quo?

  • Does the customer know which channel to turn to after delivery?

Frequently Asked Questions

Should you insert something into every order? Not necessarily. A discount code can be systematic, while a gift should remain exceptional.

Combien de temps avant de mesurer l’effet ? Expect a few weeks for a code to be used quickly, and up to two months for a considered purchase.

Can you offer a discount in exchange for a review? No. This practice is perceived as buying reviews and can harm your brand image.

To deepen the customer relationship on social media and product pages, read our articles on customer service on social media and on customer questions transformed into blocks on the product page.

Enzo

October 28, 2026

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.