E-commerce
October 28, 2026
Are you wondering if selling on Amazon is really worth it for your store? The short answer: yes, the visibility is immense, but it comes at the cost of margins, independence, and customer relationships. Amazon pursues a clear goal: to be the destination where you can find any product, always in stock, at the lowest price. Every seller must therefore ask themselves if they accept the consequences of this logic on their other channels.
The classic trap: rushing to take advantage of the audience without measuring what you abandon along the way. It is better to weigh the trade-offs with full knowledge and data in hand, rather than discovering the side effects afterward.
So, selling on Amazon: what compromises must you really accept? On the agenda:
Why does a massive customer base come with fierce competition?
Does Amazon cannibalize traffic to your own site?
Who truly owns the customer in an Amazon sale?
Should you entrust your logistics and customer service to Amazon?
How does Qstomy help you keep control over your customers?
Let's go.
Summary
Why does a massive customer base come with fierce competition?
Few channels offer more than 240 million consumer product buyers. This is Amazon's major asset: a colossal audience, already accustomed to buying, with a solid average order value. For a merchant, it is a gateway to volumes difficult to reach alone.
But this audience also attracts more than two million sellers, each seeking their place. Sales objectives, cost structures, and supply capabilities vary enormously from one seller to another. Result: pressure on margins increases every year.
Flexible sellers, who understand their costs in detail and secure exclusive sourcing or their own brand, come out on top. Without this advantage, you suffer from permanent price comparison.
What this means for you
Before you launch, list what makes you difficult to copy: sourcing, brand, service, exclusive range. If the answer is 'nothing', Amazon will remain a race track where you run against everyone.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.
The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion



Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants
Does Amazon cannibalize traffic to your own site?
Your customers often start their search on Amazon or Google. As soon as you become a third-party seller, Amazon starts bidding on Google keywords that could lead to your product listings. These listings then appear at the top of the results, sometimes ahead of your own site.
This is the classic scenario of a brand seller who was thriving on their site, joins Amazon, and then notices a drop in traffic to their own pages. You pay more for the same keywords, or you lose your position to Amazon.
Another effect: a customer who searched for your brand on Google now finds it directly on Amazon and no longer needs to return to your store. The real effect remains moderate, however, as many searches now start on Amazon itself.
How to limit the damage
Monitor your strategic keywords and strengthen your own SEO. To go further, consult our guide on the functioning of SEO for e-commerce sites.
Who truly owns the customer in an Amazon sale?
On Amazon, all buyers are Amazon customers. As a third-party seller, your sales are made to their customers, not yours. And you are not allowed to contact them again later.
Building a lasting relationship with these buyers therefore becomes almost impossible. A sale on Amazon rarely leads to a repurchase of your product. The customer will likely return to buy on Amazon, but from the seller who wins the Buy Box at that moment, not necessarily from you.
Amazon uses an algorithm to decide which seller's offer gets added to the cart. Over 90% of non-media product sales come from the seller who wins this Buy Box. Your performance, availability, prices, and shipping method directly impact your chances.
The real challenge
You rent the audience; you do not own the relationship. Therefore, any retention strategy must be built elsewhere, on channels you control.
Should you entrust your logistics and customer service to Amazon?
Amazon offers sellers to ship their orders via its dedicated logistics service. You send your products in bulk to their centers, and Amazon handles shipping, most customer inquiries, and returns.
This operational advantage does not exist on any other marketplace. It frees up time for you to focus on sourcing and product development rather than daily operations.
This service also offers an advantage for the Buy Box: offers shipped this way are favored in the algorithm, increasing your chances of winning the sale.
The downside
You delegate customer relationships and returns to a third party. You lose control over the post-purchase experience and the data it generates. To maintain this control, compare with our delivery strategies to reduce costs.
Is growth really easier on Amazon?
Few marketplaces offer such scale. The existing audience, buyer trust, and integrated logistics make growth accessible faster than elsewhere. For a merchant wanting to test a product, it is an effective testing ground.
However, this ease comes with a structural cost. Your margins depend on commissions, logistics fees, and competitive pressure. And this growth does not belong to you: it remains dependent on Amazon's rules and algorithm.
The right approach is to consider Amazon as one acquisition channel among others, not your main store. You gain volume, but you must continue building your own asset in parallel.
A channel, not a foundation
Treat Amazon as a temporary lever. Your brand and your website remain what sustains you, regardless of the current channel.
How to protect your margin against price pressure?
The more sellers there are, the greater the pressure on margins. Without exclusive sourcing or your own brand, you suffer this pressure more intensely each year.
The countermeasure lies in three simple levers. First, an identifiable brand that justifies a price premium. Second, sourcing that others cannot easily copy. Finally, a complementary range that increases the average order value.
Marque : a strong identity reduces direct comparison.
Sourcing : exclusivity takes you out of the race corridor.
Gamme : add-ons increase value per order.
To leverage this, read our original and effective pricing strategies.
Why does the Buy Box decide your visibility?
The Buy Box is the box that allows the customer to add a product to the cart with one click. Amazon determines which of its sellers wins this spot based on several criteria: performance, availability, price, and shipping method.
The stakes are huge. Over 90% of non-media product sales go through this winning seller. Losing the Buy Box means losing most of the visibility on the product page, even if your offer remains present.
This means your success depends on factors partially outside your control, such as Amazon's decisions or the arrival of a more aggressive competitor. You must therefore monitor your metrics continuously.
Your priority
Maintain reliable stock, consistent prices, and fulfilled delivery times. These are the most direct levers to stay in the Buy Box.
What do you lose in terms of customer data?
On Amazon, you cannot retrieve your buyers' contact details to re-engage them. You therefore lose direct access to your customer data, a central asset for any merchant.
Without this data, it is difficult to recover abandoned carts, suggest complementary products, or measure a customer's lifetime value. You sell, but you learn almost nothing about your audience.
This is one of the most costly trade-offs in the long term. Your own site, however, gives you emails, purchase history, and preferences that you can freely leverage.
Take back control
Focus your customer relationship efforts on your own channels. Our advice on customer relationship for high-value products shows you how to reassure and retain customers.
Should you replicate the same strategy on Shopify and Amazon?
No, and it is a common pitfall. Amazon and your Shopify store follow two opposing logics. On Amazon, you play for visibility, volume, and the Buy Box. On your own site, you build the brand, margin, and loyalty.
Replicating the same offers and prices everywhere weakens both channels. On Amazon, your prices are constantly compared. On your site, your customers expect an experience and service that justify the direct purchase.
Therefore, clearly distinguish the roles: Amazon for acquisition, your store for relationship and long-term value. Can you even sell Amazon products on Shopify? We address this question in our dedicated article.
Deux canaux, deux missions
Traitez chaque canal selon son objectif. Voir aussi Can you sell Amazon products on Shopify.
How to decide if the game is worth the candle?
It all comes down to one question: do you accept Amazon's effects on your other channels? If the answer is yes, the marketplace can become a real growth engine. If no, it is better to strengthen your own site.
Do the calculation coldly. Estimate the accessible volume, deduct commissions and logistics fees, then compare with the margin you lose on your own site. Add the hidden cost of cannibalization and abandoned customer relationships.
This equation plays out over time. A channel that seemed profitable can degrade with competition. Therefore, keep several levers active rather than betting everything on one.
The right posture
Treat Amazon as a measured and reversible test. To strengthen the other side, see how to increase e-commerce store sales.
How does Qstomy help you keep control over your customers?
Amazon deprives you of direct relationship with the buyer. Qstomy, an AI agent for Shopify, returns it to your own store. It guides the buyer toward purchase with personalized recommendations, upsell, and cross-sell, then manages the cart, package tracking, customer accounts, and after-sales service.
Concretely, where Amazon decides for you, Qstomy lets you pilot the experience. Over 100 merchants already use it to turn visits into orders and buyers into loyal customers.
For a merchant who also sells on Amazon, this is the complementary piece: the channel brings you volume, your store brings you a lasting relationship. One does not replace the other; they compensate each other.
What you gain
Conversion : recommendations that guide to the right product.
Panier moyen : upsell and cross-sell at the right moment.
Confiance : integrated package tracking and after-sales service.
To go further, explore smart product recommendations and our advice on SEO qui fonctionnent vraiment.
What checklist before launching on Amazon?
In short
Every advantage of Amazon has a cost: competition, cannibalization, customer loss, logistics dependency. The channel accelerates your sales, but it does not build your brand.
Checklist before you launch
Clarity : do you know what makes you hard to copy?
Marge : are commissions and logistics fees quantified?
Trafic : do you monitor your keywords against Amazon?
Clients : do you collect their data on your site?
Tests : do you treat Amazon as a reversible channel?
Frequently Asked Questions
Amazon peut-il vraiment booster mes ventes ? Yes, thanks to its massive audience, provided you accept its margin and customer relationship constraints.
Can I keep my store alongside it? Yes, and it's even recommended: your site remains your durable asset and your loyalty channel.

Enzo
October 28, 2026


