E-commerce

What myths about Amazon private labels need to be debunked?

What myths about Amazon private labels need to be debunked?

October 28, 2026

Are you wondering if Amazon private labels will crush yours? The short answer: no, and this isn't an opinion; it's what the categories where Amazon launched its own products show. Understanding these mechanisms prevents you from making strategic decisions based on fear rather than facts.

The topic is tricky: Amazon launching a private label looks like a threat, yet it often draws attention and buyers to an entire category. Merchants who panic change their positioning too quickly; those who read the situation correctly emerge stronger.

One point deserves to be highlighted immediately: the debate on private labels isn't new to Amazon. It replays, at a digital scale, a question that physical retailers have asked for decades. The difference lies in visibility, not the nature of the phenomenon.

So, what myths about Amazon private labels need to be debunked? Here's what's on the agenda:

  • Why did Amazon launch around 70 private labels, and what does this really mean?

  • Can an Amazon private label truly dominate an entire category?

  • Does Amazon have an interest in stifling third-party sellers?

  • Are younger generations really unfaithful to brands?

  • How does Qstomy help turn this ecosystem into an advantage?

Let's go.

Summary

Why do Amazon private labels worry brands so much?

Amazon has launched around 70 private labels to date. This figure is enough to fuel doomsday scenarios for some observers, convinced that the giant will absorb each category one by one. Yet, private labels are not an Amazon invention.

Target, Walmart, and supermarket chains have been exploiting this model for decades across virtually every imaginable category. The only real difference is where the buyer browses the aisle: a screen rather than a physical store.

Remember: no national brand has closed its doors due to a retailer's private labels. Fear is understandable, but it deserves to be examined in light of facts, not headlines. To position yourself within this ecosystem, start with a strategy tailored for small brands.

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Can Amazon really monopolize an entire category?

This is myth number one. The launch of Solimo, Amazon's razor and shaving product brand, triggered a wave of worried messages, even from Australia, to teams managing a major competing brand on the marketplace.

The scenario seemed preordained: massive advertising, aggressive pricing, polished brand pages, dominant positioning in search results. Everything suggested that other razor manufacturers would disappear.

The opposite happened. The category gained visibility, and sales of managed products increased by more than 20% month over month. A private label does not eliminate demand; it broadens attention to the aisle.

This pattern repeats elsewhere. When a retailer launches its brand, it invests in the category: advertising budgets, internal SEO, and prominent placement. This influx of resources puts the product in front of buyers who otherwise would never have explored that aisle. The incumbent brand inherits some of this attention, provided it is visible and convincing at the right moment.

Does Amazon have an interest in stifling third-party sellers?

Many small sellers, like large brands, believe Amazon favors its own products to the detriment of theirs. This reading ignores what Amazon truly is: a machine to maximize variety and transactions.

Amazon wants more third-party brands, not fewer. It wants to offer the widest possible selection at the best prices. Stifling sellers would directly contradict this goal. If the platform sold only its private labels, its overall revenue would collapse.

In other words, your presence fuels Amazon's engine. All the more reason to optimize your product listing and visibility, for example with a clean integration between Shopify and Amazon for your products, inventory, and reviews.

What if customers had become unfaithful to brands?

The argument keeps recurring: consumers are becoming less attached to brands and would willingly switch to cheaper alternatives. Yet this discourse has existed for decades without being verified.

In reality, Apple, Coca-Cola, Disney, and Toyota sell more every year. Brand attachment has not disappeared; it has shifted channels, not nature.

A customer choosing an Amazon alternative $2 cheaper is not the universal norm. It exists, but it coexists with a majority of buyers who remain loyal to what they know and recognize. Building your growth on this loyalty remains a solid strategy, as shown by the jump from 0 to 7 figures.

The real issue is not whether loyalty exists, but whether your brand nurtures it. Consumers are not unfaithful by nature; they are volatile when the promise is interchangeable. A strong identity, impeccable service, and a consistent experience create a preference that price alone cannot overturn.

Are millennials really insensitive to brands?

No, and this is one of the most persistent myths. Millennials are just as materialistic as previous generations. Materialism has not died in the selfie era.

Take Cardi B: 34 million followers on Instagram. If she posted a video of herself eating Kellogg's Frosted Flakes, some of her followers would buy the box. None of them would take the generic version from Amazon, even if it was $2 cheaper.

In terms of numbers, 50% of Gucci's customers are millennials, and Yves Saint Laurent has a 65% millennial customer base. Brand loyalty is doing very well, thank you.

Has Instagram really changed the game for brands?

Instagram has become the primary source of inspiration for millennials following celebrities and influencers. When a personality wears specific makeup or clothing, their followers want the same.

Fashion Nova is the perfect example: the most searched clothing brand on Instagram, according to its own CEO. Celebrities showcase the brand, mention @fashionnova, and followers buy, post, and add the #novababe hashtag. Result: a viral brand.

Fashion Nova won't lose its business to a generic tank top from Amazon. The same logic applies to yoga wear, lipsticks, makeup sponges, pore cleansers, masks, and tea.

This mechanism reveals a useful truth for any merchant: demand is built socially. An identical product sold without a story or belonging remains a commodity; the same product associated with a community becomes an object of desire. That is where the difference lies against a private label, regardless of its distribution power.

Is a cheaper version enough to steal your customers?

The logic of the lowest price does not hold. Just because Amazon offers a cheaper version of a product does not mean established brands risk losing their sales.

Amazon is the new local supermarket. Like its physical predecessors, it displays goods side by side, national brand next to private label. The only difference: the buyer uses the site's search instead of browsing the aisles.

The customer compares, yes, but they do not compare only price. They compare trust, image, and promise. Your job is to make this comparison favorable for you, which also involves the difference between e-commerce marketing and advertising.

Do Amazon's private labels cause more damage than those in supermarkets?

No. Amazon's private labels will not cause more damage than those of supermarket chains or specialized hypermarkets. The mechanism is identical, the scale is simply more visible.

The good news is that the advertising Amazon deploys for its private labels highlights the relevant categories. This visibility also benefits competing brands present on the marketplace.

Nothing in observed behaviors suggests that innovation will destroy brands anytime soon. Your adversary is not the private label: it is invisibility. Work your category pages with a dedicated SEO strategy to stay in the race.

One must also distinguish the scale of media visibility. When Amazon moves, the press seizes the topic, creating the impression of an earthquake. But in most categories, the shockwave remains local and measurable. Merchants who follow their own data rather than headlines maintain a lead.

How to turn Amazon's presence into an opportunity?

Category growth attracts new buyers, and not all these buyers turn to the private label. Some seek the national brand, the premium version, the reference they already know.

Your role: capture this attention at the right moment. Targeted category ads, strong product pages, well-managed reviews, clear presence on channels where your audience spends time.

A well-thought-out social media campaign can capitalize on this influx. To lay the foundations, rely on a structured Facebook strategy. The goal is not to beat Amazon on its turf, but to win preference on yours.

Why do so many merchants panic for nothing?

Panic often stems from a misunderstanding of the model. A private label launch resembles a declaration of war, when it is actually a classic commercial move amplified by Amazon's visibility.

Many sellers and major brands measure neither Amazon's true objectives nor the actual behavior of buyers. They react to emotion, not data.

Before revising your entire positioning, check what is actually happening in your category. A business that fails in its first 12 months rarely does so because of a private label, but often for more concrete reasons, as detailed in this analysis of e-commerce failures.

The emotional reaction has a real cost: rushed line revamps, panic price cuts, abandoning a profitable channel. All decisions made in a state of worry that then weigh on margins. Analytical discipline, however, transforms this worry into a competitive advantage.

How does Qstomy help leverage this ecosystem?

Qstomy is a Shopify AI agent designed to guide the buyer to purchase. Where Amazon displays all options side by side, your store must instead guide, reassure, and save time. This is exactly Qstomy's role, used by over 100 merchants.

Ce que l’agent prend en charge

  • Recommandations : recommends the right product based on the expressed need, rather than letting the buyer get lost.

  • Upsell and cross-sell : increases basket value at the moment the decision is made.

  • Basket and conversion : removes final doubts before payment.

  • Order tracking and after-sales service : answers delivery and account questions, and manages return policies.

Faced with a cheaper private label, your best weapon is a smooth and personalized shopping experience. If you also sell products already available on Amazon, know what reselling them on your Shopify store entails.

What checklist to follow before reacting to an Amazon private label?

In short

  • Amazon has launched around 70 private labels, but the model has existed for decades among all distributors.

  • The launch of Solimo increased competitors' sales by over 20% month over month.

  • Amazon wants more third-party brands because its revenue depends on variety and low prices.

  • Brand loyalty remains strong, even among millennials.

FAQ

Should you fear an Amazon private label in your category?

Not in principle. First, verify the actual data for your category before modifying your positioning.

Do private labels reduce sales for established brands?

Not in observed cases: the category gains visibility and competitor sales can increase.

Does Amazon favor its own brands to the detriment of third-party sellers?

That would go against its objectives: it seeks the widest possible selection at the best price.

Are young buyers less loyal to brands?

Non. Gucci compte 50 % de clients millennials, Yves Saint Laurent 65 %.

What concrete action to take before panicking?

Analyze your data, strengthen your pages and purchase guidance, then decide based on facts.

Enzo

October 28, 2026

Convert over 2,000 customers on average per month with Qstomy.

The world’s 1st Shopify AI dedicated to customer conversion

Empowering 200+ e-commerce merchants

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.

Subscribe to the newsletter and get a personalized e-book!

No-code solution, no technical knowledge required. AI trained on your e-shop and non-intrusive.

*Unsubscribe at any time. We do not send spam.